The black powder cartridge weapons in "Hostiles".

Status
Not open for further replies.
Eastern Indians wanted their opponent to run. They figured to run them down and it was greater sport for them to do so. Sending the wife and kids to the ridge which required running out in the open was suicidal. Normally everyone would barricade the doors and window in anticipation of an assault. But like CraigC's father would say, it was in the script.

The Indian Artifacts on the Colonel's walls weren't exactly correct. The pipe tomahawk blades were bigger and wider out West and the one on the wall would fit into the 1760s era.

The second fort where they picked the prisoner was too congested. Should have been a big parade ground between the structures. Camp Verde, Laramie and other forts were like that. Now Fort Massachusetts in Alamosa, CO was an enclosed wood fort but the wood was horizontal and filled with dirt. Fort Garland which replaced it (Garland, CO), was open with a parade ground and did not have defensive walls like virtually all other SW forts. Fort Union in New Mexico didn't have a defensive structure until a star shape earth fort was thrown up 2 miles from the bluffs that overlooked Fort Union. It was well out of range of the 12 pdr mountain howitzers that Sibley had when he tried to conquer the SW for the Confederacy.
 
I'm in Africa. I watched it on the small screen.
My take on the the movie - I dozed off briefly. Looking at western genre movies in the past 3 years, Bone Tomahawk and Magnificent 7 were a better movies.
Overall score - 1 meh.
Long, dark-ish, but no awards given.

My rating - OK movie but not a great movie.

Edit: Hindsight being 20/20 - would I pay full price to see it in a theater?
Yes I would.
 
Good morning,
Saw the movie last night and really enjoyed it. Dark but unfortunately realistic as life seemed to be cheap and thrown away like trash back in those days. The under laying theme of how 'rough n' tough' dealt with loss was out on display during the whole film. I know these guys only had a couple of hours to cover the Captains transformation from roping up 'Injuns' to befriending a mortal enemy with respect and dignity but it still seemed rushed. Bale did a great job with what he was given to work with as did all the cast, especially Laura Dern. Those 'Rattlesnake Tribe' guys were vicious as Hel and kind of reminded me of the tribe in Bone Tomahawk ( another excellently done Western ) Beautiful scenery and a picture of a West that still exists just minus that particular eras worth of character types. I need to get another Cavalry .45. *chuckles*
regards all!

A great quote from Lonesome Dove and Longmire: "This godd*&$n country has burned up all my tears"
 
Last edited:
Good morning,
Saw the movie last night and really enjoyed it. Dark but unfortunately realistic as life seemed to be cheap and thrown away like trash back in those days. The under laying theme of how 'rough n' tough' dealt with loss was out on display during the whole film. I know these guys only had a couple of hours to cover the Captains transformation from roping up 'Injuns' to befriending a mortal enemy with respect and dignity but it still seemed rushed. Bale did a great job with what he was given to work with as did all the cast, especially Laura Dern. Those 'Rattlesnake Tribe' guys were vicious as Hel and kind of reminded me of the tribe in Bone Tomahawk ( another excellently done Western ) Beautiful scenery and a picture of a West that still exists just minus that particular eras worth of character types. I need to get another Cavalry .45. *chuckles*
regards all!

A great quote from Lonesome Dove and Longmire: "This godd*&$n country has burned up all my tears"

Laura Dern wasn't in that picture. You might be thinking of Rosamund Pike and, yes, she was great.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top