FMJ =the best was PS Grand which is no longer imported.
PS Grand 95-gr FMJ (10 rounds tested)
Manufacturer: PS Grand a.s., Bytca, Slovakia
Headstamp: PS 9mm M
Cartridge Case: Brass case, Boxer primed, non-corrosive primer
Bullet: 94.6-gr (1 measured), steel-jacketed copper-coated with concave exposed-lead base
Magnetic: Cartridge case – no; bullet jacket is magnetic
OAL (ins)
Range: 0.967 – 0.974
Avg: 0.970
Velocity: (fps)
Range: 1041 - 1093
Avg: 1070
ES: 52
SD: 17
HP =the old Corbon which is no longer made.
Cor-Bon 95-gr JHP (10 rounds tested)
No longer manufactured.
Manufacturer: CorBon/Glaser, Sturgis, South Dakota
Headstamp: *-* 9x18 MAK (Starline brass)
Cartridge Case: Brass case (Starline), Boxer primed, non-corrosive primer
Bullet: 94.9-gr (1 measured) copper-coated with flat copper-coated base
Magnetic: Case and bullet are non-magnetic
OAL (ins)
Range: 0.946 – 0.950
Avg: 0.948
Velocity: (fps)
Range: 1123 - 1153
Avg: 1135
ES: 30
SD: 9
Based on your choices I woud go with fiocchi or another good FMJ found on northbender's list. The Hornady is a weak round compared to others in the 9x18 world. Unfortunately not many choices of 9x18 ammo (the bears, fiocchi and hornady are the most common seen) anymore.
Fiocchi 95-gr FMJ (20 rounds tested)
Manufacturer: Unclear; This ammunition is labeled "Made in European Union", which could have been in Hungary or Italy
Headstamp: G.F.L. 9 MAKAROV
Cartridge Case: Brass case, Boxer primed, non-corrosive primer
Bullet: 94.5-gr (1 measured), copper (brass?)-coated, with concave exposed-lead base
Magnetic: Case and bullet are non-magnetic
OAL (ins)
Range: 0.970 – 0.975
Avg: 0.972
Velocity: (fps)
Range: 976 – 1077
Avg: 1040
ES: 101
SD: 27
Hornady 95-gr JHP (20 rounds tested)
Manufacturer: Hornady Manufacturing Co., Grand Island, NE
Headstamp: HORNADY 9X18 MAKAROV
Cartridge Case: Brass case, Boxer primed, non-corrosive primer
Bullet: 94.6-gr (1 measured), copper coated with flat copper base
Magnetic: Case and bullet are non-magnetic
OAL (ins)
Range: 0.933 – 0.940
Avg: 0.939
Velocity: (fps)
Range: 908 - 956
Avg: 934
ES: 48
SD: 15