For me it isn't as interesting what the averages are as why they are. Why does the typical gunfight only involve 1-3 rounds? Is it because that is all it takes to incapacitate the attacker(s)?
No, it is because they typically run away. So, if one prepares for that scenario they are prepping for undetermined attackers who will run. Odds are extremely good that will be the case and having a gun (any gun) will do and no, or minimal, training is required. (It also means all this talk about accuracy is moot as well, people aren't hitting squat in these typical 1-3rd self defense stories by and large, just making noise, winging 'em and they run)
Personally, I just can't bring myself to rely on them running or prepare for the best case (even if the overwhelmingly most common) scenario. That said, I'm a realist and have been in many dangerous places. I don't carry 2 high cap guns plus spare mags for both, tac knife, blowout kit etc as EDC. I don't carry a derringer either.
For me, shootability of the gun takes priority. Needs good grip, sights, and recoil characteristics. By the time that is met, in an auto for me that means at least a 7 shot single stack 9mm or if double stack at least 10-12 minimum in a small, but very shootable gun. I mostly carry a P226 just because I shoot it best and don't mind the size and weight. I would be shocked to ever need my flush-fit 18+1, but since I like the gun and shoot it well, why not?
No, it is because they typically run away. So, if one prepares for that scenario they are prepping for undetermined attackers who will run. Odds are extremely good that will be the case and having a gun (any gun) will do and no, or minimal, training is required. (It also means all this talk about accuracy is moot as well, people aren't hitting squat in these typical 1-3rd self defense stories by and large, just making noise, winging 'em and they run)
Personally, I just can't bring myself to rely on them running or prepare for the best case (even if the overwhelmingly most common) scenario. That said, I'm a realist and have been in many dangerous places. I don't carry 2 high cap guns plus spare mags for both, tac knife, blowout kit etc as EDC. I don't carry a derringer either.
For me, shootability of the gun takes priority. Needs good grip, sights, and recoil characteristics. By the time that is met, in an auto for me that means at least a 7 shot single stack 9mm or if double stack at least 10-12 minimum in a small, but very shootable gun. I mostly carry a P226 just because I shoot it best and don't mind the size and weight. I would be shocked to ever need my flush-fit 18+1, but since I like the gun and shoot it well, why not?