PCCs, being blowback, have as much perceived recoil as 5.56
This is why I advocate that we need more guns like the 30 Carbine, which operate from a locked breech. With a fixed breech, the rest of the gun can be scaled down along with the cartridge, to the point you have a handgun. I personally do not know why no pistol caliber
recoil-operated guns based on handgun chassis are offered, since a longer-barreled PX4 pistol with a stock would be well under 5 pounds, be much smaller than an AR or similar, have a round more suited to the task at hand, be independent of gas-op peculiarities, and cost no more to make than a handgun (less materials). Scaled-down gas-op guns like the M1 Carbine have many benefits, but cost as much to make as a full-size rifle version, and it's much easier to sell the bigger gun if the cost is the same
.
I think a long-barreled/stocked Steyr TMP would be a fantastic defensive carbine.
Dial down the sight, replace the can with a foregrip tube, add a sturdier and more comfortable stock, and you'll have what I'm going for (I'd want it in 7.62x25, but whatever
). The rotating barrel lockup will be more amenable to a barrel length increase than a tilting Browning design.
To the "AR is bettur" guys, know this; pistol-caliber subguns ruled the roost for over fifty years (1930's to the 1980's) during which the AR and 223 were both present for a good portion. That's about as long as bolt-rifles were popular with militaries, and we have no questions about
their effectiveness. AR carbines have been super popular for around half that time, and among civvies for what, five years or so? I wouldn't reject 70+ years of solid, reliable performance for the new kid on the block just yet
And can your AR do this?
"My general rule is keep rifle calibers in rifles, and pistol calibers in pistols"
Who decides what is a "rifle caliber" or a "pistol caliber" and what does 30 Carbine count as? 500 S&W? What about 45 Win Mag, 357, 10mm, 7.62x25, 5.7x28? Where is the line drawn, and why? Neither revolvers nor bolo pistols need the rounds to fit in a hand grip, after all
If not for our dumb SBR laws, not a single railed pistol would go without a foregrip and stock unless it was used for daily concealed carry. There's a reason pistol ranges are usually about a quarter as long as rifle ranges, and it's not because the guns are less accurate
. Control, retention, stability, and control (again).
TCB