nothing wrong with reviewing an old topic imo.. alot can change in time, hence be learned in good topics like this!
Ive had a good few 9mm's, had 2 .38'. between the two cal's Im down to 2 9's and 1 .38.
each of them, I have tried various SD loads with, on hard and soft targets, and different scenarios.. Ive retrieved many many bullets for examination of preformance..
Overall, the 9mm will preform more effectively in every situation IME.. It has more pennetration, more expansion, and more impact weight.
and in far more cases than not, the 9mm weapon platform allows for a higher capacity aswell.
The .38 is a real good contender imo tho, and does have its situation specific advantages over the 9mm ime. I dont question its ability to stop someone if applied correctly, like any load.. and Id feel a bit more comfortable with over pennetration issues inside my home.
I have some test rounds from various targets, from both the 9mm and .38spl.. Ill photo them and post pics up a bit later.. Im shure everyone will enjoy them.
ip