Interesting question. My gut reaction is "yes," of course we're drawn to what we started with, but in my case the answer is "no." My dad did a lot of bird hunting, and the first two guns I owned, which he gave me, were a .410 and a 20 gauge shotgun. At the time (probably about 14 or 15 years old), I thought it was really cool that those two guns were mine. I used them both for bird and trap shooting.
Years ago, someone broke into my parents' house and took all the guns, including my two shotguns. During my 20s and most of my 30s, I didn't think about guns, and almost never shot any except for a couple bird hunting trips each year. But then I started to get more interested. However, I was most interested in rifles and handguns, which my dad had never owned and which I had never shot (well, almost never, there were a few hunting weekends with buddies at remote cabins that involved some rifle and handgun target shooting). Over the last 10 years, everything I've bought has been a rifle or a handgun, neither of which is close to what I started on.
This surprises me, but it is what it is.