helitack32f1
Member
I think what you are missing is the fact that most people are now realizing or buying into the belief that most real world scenarios for defense are at distances of 7 yards or less so there is no need for IDPA accuracy at farther distances. There are also a lot of people who are uncomfortable enough with a larger gun that they are more likely than not to leave it at home rather than deal with discomfort or the perceived effort necessary to conceal the larger weapon.I now only own guns that have a full grip. I cannot shoot anything less well in 9mm (as small as I go) or .45acp (as large as I go). Significant differences in proficiency and competence matter more to me than slight differences in carry comfort. I no longer own or carry a gun I cannot speed/action shoot well.
IMO too many sacrifice significant levels of competence for slight differences in comfort by carrying tiny guns. (Hardly no one runs these tiny guns in IDPA, and for good reason.) This is the "better to have a gun..." (i.e. any gun) crowd, and they stop after the "gun" part of that sentence.
The right belt and holster make larger guns carry best, whereas with tiny guns pretty much anything works. Me, I'm the "find a way to make the guns you shoot best work" crowd. And, I only select 9mm in higher capacity. So, currently, my rotation is a 14+1 (+1 spare) 9mm, or a 7+1 (+2 spares) or 10+1 (+1 spare) .45acp. I know I can hit what I aim at with these guns, because I do reliably, and that's instills confidence that trumps their size or weight.
There are a lot of people who buy the smaller guns so they have something to throw into their pocket for quick trips or wandering around the house. These little big bore guns have a place. I bought an lcp for just those times. Then I sold it because I realized I never actually packed it around. I have had a hard time finding situations where I cannot comfortably pack my Glock 23 in a Crossbreed holster.
I cannot justify replacing the 13 rounds of .40 of the Glock with 6 rounds of .45 in the XDS, but I sure as heck can justify that 6 rounds of .45 over 6 rounds of .380, or nothing at all.