I'm always amazed at how a tool that has worked in a designated role for over 100 years can all of a sudden not function in that role (revolver in combat). Prolonged pistol fighting in real combat? I think the weapon (revolver or auto) will survive longer than the users. If I were a soldier in the heat of a modern battle (Iraq or Afghanistan), and forced to use a pistol against enemy with rifles, etc, I think I had better quickly shoot an enemy, and get my hands on a rifle. If six or so shots doesn't do it, I am already in trouble, aren't I? I really don't think it matters, revolver or auto, both are on the weak and inefficient side, but MAY get you into a better weapon, or safer place. For what it's worth, I think my stainless Ruger Sheriff's Model .44 Special would stand up to combat conditions, with reasonable care and maintenance, as well as a Beretta M9, and maybe even a Colt 1911 or Glock. Shy of willful neglect or freak damage, I think it can function with the best.