Bullets by prescription?

Status
Not open for further replies.

fletcher

Member
Joined
May 19, 2004
Messages
2,561
Location
Greensboro, NC
As far as gun control proposals go, this is WAY out there:

http://media.www.dailytarheel.com/media/storage/paper885/news/2007/09/06/StateNational/Pharmacist.Proposes.Gun.Control.Measure-2952909.shtml

Media Credit: DTH photo illustration/Allie Mullin
David Work, former head of the N.C. Board of Pharmacy believes that effective gun control in the United States can be achieved through requiring doctors to write prescriptions for patients to buy ammunition.


Since retiring from leading the N.C. Board of Pharmacy, David Work is promoting a new role for medical prescriptions: gun control.

Work, a former UNC professor of pharmacy law, said he thinks the best way to reduce the number of gun-related crimes is to regulate access to ammunition in the same way doctors regulate drugs - by having physicians prescribe bullets.

"It's a serious proposal," he said. "It's thinking outside the box."

The U.S. ranks highest in the world for civilian firearm possession - a study by the Small Arms Survey, an independent research project in Geneva, found that there are 90 civilian-owned guns in the U.S. for every 100 citizens.

Ammunition is easier to buy than guns, Work said, and individuals who obtain guns illegally can buy bullets at a gun dealer easily if they're 18 or older.

Work said gun and ammunition laws have dangerous loopholes, as illustrated by the Virginia Tech campus shooting that killed 32 students and faculty in April.

The criminal record of the shooter, Seung-Hui Cho, was misleadingly clean from a law-enforcement perspective, Work said, but a professional physician quickly would have spotted Cho's mental instability.

"A family physician knows his or her patients," he said.

Paul Valone, president of Grass Roots North Carolina, a gun-owner's advocacy group, supports the easy availability of ammunition and said it prevents a black market that would be impossible for law enforcement to combat.

"Ammunition is very easily produced," he said, adding that he made about 10,000 rounds of ammunition per year when he shot competitively. "In the unlikely event that they succeed in restricting ammunition sales, they will create a black market in ammunition sales that will make meth labs look pale by comparison."

It's the duty of the courts to decide who's fit to bear arms, he said, "not an arbitrary determination by a physician or a psychologist on whether someone is fit to exercise their rights."

Lisa Price, executive director of North Carolinians Against Gun Violence, said she agreed with Work's intentions but not the prescription-based proposal.

"I can see how doctors could see good and bad aspects of someone's character, but I just think this would be difficult to work out," she said.

Price said she preferred a compromise between the current system and Work's idea. She proposed that the rules to buy ammunition should be the same as those to buy a gun.

"We've already got a model of checking into someone's background," she said. "I think the same laws that apply to buying a gun should apply to buying bullets."

Work said a new system is necessary, even if it's not his prescription-bullet proposal.

"Because what we've got does not work for the safety of the people."



Contact the State & National Editor at [email protected].


This is priceless:
Ammunition is easier to buy than guns, Work said, and individuals who obtain guns illegally can buy bullets at a gun dealer easily if they're 18 or older.
Then what makes you think they won't also obtain ammunition illegally?
 
It's the duty of the courts to decide who's fit to bear arms, he said, "not an arbitrary determination by a physician or a psychologist on whether someone is fit to exercise their rights.

I disagree with this. The Constitution doesn't mention having anyone decide who is fit to exercise their inherent rights.
 
Will my HMO cover my ammo?

Doctors kill more people than "gun violence" each year. They are in no position to talk.
 
Lemme see...

Are there generic substitutes?
What's the copay for brand name cartridges like Federal?
Do they do 90 day supplies by mail order?
How much ammo constitutes a 90 day supply?
What about FDA approval?
Will they start selling ammo at Walgreen's?
 
Can I get 5 dollar copay on .308 and M193?

Hmm, it has possibilities.....



(this is the dumbest idea i have heard in a long time)
 
makes as much since as the idiot that was wanting to put diapers on animals a few decades ago. The world is full of fools if some one will give them attention.
 
Odd that people think they can legislate themselves into safety. After paying huge taxes for law enforcement and law creation we are still no safer from someone who decides to break these laws. I fail to see why people still believe there is some undiscovered magical law that will prevent all crime.

Instead of spending more money on more laws, and driving up the debt with more supposed "enforcement" agencies, how about:
1. Cutting government bureaucracy/out of control spending.
2. Enjoying life as free men/women, but being willing and able to defend that life rather then spend billions of dollars just so you can ask the crook to hold on for 10-20 minutes so you can dial the police, give them directions and explain the situation, then wait for them to show up to save the day.

Up here in Canada if you're a law-abiding citizen that has never broken the law, yet you arm yourself so that there is a chance you might live when attacked, you are breaking the law and will be thrown in jail.

We have a case in the courts right now where a man refused to give pan-handlers money, so they stabbed him to death. Now the superior courts just overturned the remand order and granted low bail to one of the attackers "because time in solitary confinement for the killer would be difficult." Wow, how hard a time is it for the victim WHO IS DEAD ?!

Please don't let yourselves in the U.S. get as looney and government-controlled as we are in canada...
 
"We've already got a model of checking into someone's background," she said. "I think the same laws that apply to buying a gun should apply to buying bullets."

I strongly believe that this is what is coming at some point. A NICS check everytime you buy ammunition. Ammunition/primers/powder could only be purchased through an FFL. Of course, that means no mail order ammunition, and a NICS fee everytime you go to your local gun store for ammo. But since 65% of the folks in these forums see nothing wrong with background checks, they won't mind doing one for ammo, too.
 
Bah, this is just a silly attempt to get his 15 minutes by proposing something suggesting that his profession is somehow the be-all, end-all of solving the world's maladies. He's getting exactly what he wants, his name and his silly idea passed around.
 
...and obtaining drugs by prescription has completely erradicated illegal drug use, right? :rolleyes: Looks like the good doc has been taken some of his own medicine... :scrutiny:
 
.thinking outside the box.......more like outside his mind. so, people dont forge perscriptions? doctors dont 'hand-out' scripts & pharmacies have room to inventory ammo. LMAO. this isnt even worth of saturday nite live skit.
 
rdhood said:
I strongly believe that this is what is coming at some point. A NICS check everytime you buy ammunition. Ammunition/primers/powder could only be purchased through an FFL. Of course, that means no mail order ammunition, and a NICS fee everytime you go to your local gun store for ammo. But since 65% of the folks in these forums see nothing wrong with background checks, they won't mind doing one for ammo, too.

Do you think the number is that low? I'm thinking a bit higher. :)
 
I don't even know where to begin with this one. I guess I could start by pointing out that anyone who tries to apply their professional experience directly to a completely unrelated issue is an arrogant bufoon.

What he has done would be like me (an automotive technician) suggesting that people undergo an annual state inspection to be sure that they are fit to be on our streets, and those that fail must recieve surgery to correct the problem.

I don't know why some people think you can apply the same solution to every problem.
 
What the hell does ammunition have to do with medicine? This is definitely among the stupidest ideas I've ever heard.

"I think the same laws that apply to buying a gun should apply to buying bullets."

Make sure that people who buy bullets also have a gun out of which to shoot them. Can't have people just chucking 'em at each other, like they've been doing. :neener:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top