hard headed "Pit Bull" dog, shot in the head, survives.

Status
Not open for further replies.

gunsmith

member
Joined
May 8, 2003
Messages
5,906
Location
Reno, Nevada
Sounds like the lady is a pain to the local cops, I wonder what caliber they used...remind me to carry something bigger!

http://www.mankatofreepress.com/local/local_story_164200656.html?keyword=topstory

Deputy bitten, dog wounded


By Dan Nienaber
The Free Press

MANKATO —

A dog shot in the head after it bit a deputy’s foot Tuesday will likely be returned to its owner after a 10-day quarantine to check for rabies, authorities said.

Harvey, described as a 2-year-old pit bull, was shot after Blue Earth County Sheriff’s Department deputies responded to a 911 call from its owner, 45-year-old Davida Davidson of South Bend Township. Deputy Joshua Steinbach reported he had to shoot the dog once in the head because it had clamped on to his foot and wouldn’t let go.

Davidson has been in trouble with the county before for having aggressive dogs. Three of her dogs were killed by authorities a year ago after the dogs attacked a 5-year-old neighbor boy who was playing in his yard.

Steinbach was in Davidson’s garage when he was bitten. Harvey was one of several dogs that came into the garage through a back door that leads to an outside kennel.

“I calmly and quietly said, ‘Go on, get,’ at which time a black pit bull in the middle of the pack growled and started biting my right foot,” Steinbach said in his report about the incident, which happened at 8:46 p.m. Tuesday. “I then pulled my duty weapon and fired one shot at the dog. The dog let out a yelp and finally let go of my foot.”

Another deputy, John Park, was already at Davidson’s mobile home in Riverbend Estates when Steinbach arrived. Park had gone behind the mobile home to deal with a dispute between Davidson and another woman, which is why Davidson called 911.

Steinbach reported he was looking for Park when he went through Davidson’s garage door, knocked on a door to the home and, eventually, opened the door to call for Park. When there was no answer, Steinbach reported he shut the door and that’s when the dogs entered the garage.

The door has a no trespassing sign, which Davidson said she put there to protect people from Harvey and her other dogs.

“There was no reason for him to enter that door,” Davidson said Wednesday. “There never would have been a dog bite if he didn’t enter my home. The deputy put himself in harm’s way. They have to justify their actions.”

Park reported he was at a mobile home behind Davidson’s property when he heard the gun shot. He found Davidson yelling, “What did you do?” at Steinbach after he ran over to Davidson’s garage.

He told Davidson to find the dog, which had run and hidden under a step in the kennel, and checked Steinbach’s foot, Park reported. Then he told Davidson to put Harvey in the back of his squad car so he could take the dog to the Minnesota Valley Pet Hospital. Park also called a doctor, who met them at the hospital.

Steinbach was taken to Immanuel St. Joseph’s Hospital, where he was treated for a puncture wound in his small right toe and released.

Harvey is expected to survive but will be kept by authorities for at least 10 days to make sure he doesn’t have rabies, Sheriff Brad Peterson said. Davidson had not had him vaccinated for rabies within the past year and she didn’t know if he had ever been vaccinated.

Peterson said Steinbach made the correct decision when he shot the dog. Pit bulls are known to be aggressive, and Harvey had bitten through a leather boot and wouldn’t let go, Peterson said.

“If he hadn’t shot the dog, who knows what that dog would have done next,” he said. “Would he have gotten him down on the ground and went for his face?”
 
Oh this is gonna be good
Who we gonna bash here

The jack booted cops or the vicious embodiment of evil Pit Bull
 
lol

The jack booted cops or the vicious embodiment of evil Pit Bull

I think in this case it is pretty clear the dogs owner is a pain in the neck for the local constabulary.
I wonder what caliber the cop used?
 
Hard one to call with the ladies history with aggressive animals. Deputy was definately in the wrong place, and in a place the pit did consider within its territory.
 
In this case it sounds like the deputy is at fault. Dog was locked off in a safe area that the deputy did not need to be in.

As for the idiot previously having three dogs killed by police, exactly how does that justify this incident? Those dogs were obviously allowed to roam and or escaped and after atacking a child were rightly put down. This dog was (at least at this time) restrained in an appropriate way.
 
Who we gonna bash here

The jack booted cops or the vicious embodiment of evil Pit Bull

Neither did wrong.
Police responding to a 911 call tries to find out whats going on.
A dog is not responsible for the way it is bred, trained or abused.

Certainly an adult female who seems to embody the term "trash" is clearly to blame.

The door has a no trespassing sign, which Davidson said she put there to protect people from Harvey and her other dogs.

“There was no reason for him to enter that door

Then next time don't call 911. How's a cop supposed to know that you aren't lying on the floor of the home with your head caved in from the old man if he don't go looking for you.
911 is an expressed invitation for the police to enter your premises.
 
Any dog of mine that attacks, unprovoked or without being told to, gets put down. Period. If you can't control the animal, it controls you, and is a danger to others. My uncle Arley, when I was boy, shot a dog that played too rough with the kids one day. Said he wouldn't have a dog on the place that would harm a person without cause or reason.
 
Rich,
I can certainly understand that feeling. My father inlaw was the same way.

Rather than put the dog down though, train it. It is very rare that a dog cannot be trained to behave.

The show "dog whisperer" teaches that dogs will respond to the Alpha leader. Which should be its master, man.

The thing is when the dogs got your leg in its mouth, your not thinking training, your thinking survival.

Pits are some of the most loving dogs I've encountered.
 
Sounds like this was the fault of another abusive pit bull owner.
Sounds like this was also a good recipe for pulling a Kerry (shot in the foot)
Pit bulls are nice, loving dogs, but have fighting blood in them. You can't forget that.
 
How about a little communication between officers? The first officer was WITH the lady in her back yard, dealing with a neighbor. Officer number two shows up and just lets himself in the house. From the previous incident we know the "lady" has some issues, but come on the dog was properly locked up in the house, and a stranger comes in uninvited which the dog does a fine job of stopping. How is that either the dog or the ladies fault?
 
I think the cop should take a hunter safety class and learn where to shoot an animal properly. When hunting I always go for the heart/lung shot. That's what er were taught was humane hunting.
 
Another deputy, John Park, was already at Davidson’s mobile home in Riverbend Estates when Steinbach arrived. Park had gone behind the mobile home to deal with a dispute between Davidson and another woman, which is why Davidson called 911.

The Davidson woman sounds like trouble, but as a general matter think twice before calling 911 to settle disputes. Unless it is an EMERGENCY do not call 911--EVER! It's not only illegal, it may bring a much more serious reaction from local cops than you expect.
 
Yet another hard-headed pit bull: (must be something going around :uhoh:)


http://www.tylerpaper.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20070614/NEWS05/706140326

Pit Bulls Attack Smith County Constable

(Staff Photo By Tom Turner)BITTEN: Natalie Jay shows where she was bitten by a dog on Wednesday.By KENNETH DEAN
Staff Writer

DOGWOOD CITY - A Smith County deputy constable and a service man are recovering after being attacked by a pair of pit bulls.

The officer shot one of the animals while it sunk its teeth into her arm.

Natalie Jay, precinct 2 deputy constable and southern Smith County animal control officer, said she received a call of a dog bite on Water Ridge Loop in the Lakeway Harbor subdivision and she went to investigate.



CONSTABLE ATTACKED

"The dogs had reportedly attacked a man working for a local water utility company while he was turning the water on to the home where the dogs' owner was asleep," she said.

Ms. Jay said as she pulled up to the home where the worker reported the dogs attacked him she saw the dogs run off.

"I got out of the truck and began walking to the house where I saw them run, but one of the dogs suddenly came from behind the truck and the other came from underneath it," she said.

Ms. Smith said she first used her O.C. Spray (pepper spray) on the animals, but it had little effect.

"Basically it just stunned them for a few seconds and then they came right back at me," she said.

As Smith kicked at the smaller dog, which weighed 60 pounds, the larger dog, about 70 pounds, leapt through the air and grabbed her upper arm in its mouth and began biting her.

"I grabbed my handgun and fired one shot into the dog's head and he let go of me and both dogs ran away," she said.

Ms. Smith said as backup arrived they found the dogs, seized them and identified the owner.

The dogs, which were not vaccinated, were then transported to Glenwood Animal Clinic where they were euthanized and their heads sent to Austin for rabies testing.

Ms. Smith added the owner of the animals was cooperative, but had another dog in the past deemed dangerous and finally had to put the dog down.

She said the attacks Wednesday afternoon showed the county needs stricter laws.
 
this woman should not be allowed to own animals. anyone who has already had 3 dogs removed for them being vicious and attacking children obvioulsy either neglects or abuses the animals. ive met plenty of pitbulls and the majority were very friendly and well behaved. the few that werent were obvious results of the way their owner treated them.

The officer had every right to enter the premises. If you call 911 they have no way of knowing wether the dispute turned into an assault and one party was laying on the floor bleeding. if she called 911 she should have put the dogs in a room and closed the door.
 
"I grabbed my handgun and fired one shot into the dog's head and he let go of me and both dogs ran away," she said.

Harvey is expected to survive but will be kept by authorities for at least 10 days to make sure he doesn’t have rabies


Watch out folks. There must be some kinda new gunshot resistant superbreed of dogs going around:uhoh:
 
Well, if the jackbooted thug, armed with the 9mm europellet, hadn't violated this lady's constitutional right to have a vicious, bloodthirsty killer dog as a pet, none of this would have happened. The only reason to have a pit bull is to kill, and that was her right. And the only reason cops exist is to trample our rights and deprive us of our property.
 
Neither did wrong.
Police responding to a 911 call tries to find out whats going on.
A dog is not responsible for the way it is bred, trained or abused.

Reasonable responses for the most part, I am pleasantly surprised. I figured this would get locked before I got home

Dog did his job-protect his territory and pack
Cop did his job- investigate a criminal complaint
Trailer trash did her job- be trashy, once again

glockman19
How many of the deer you shot were eating your foot at the time?
Dogs usually don't just stand there and chew, they thrash around making good shot placement difficult, many people would not have been able to hit the dog at all

And I think it is commendable that he immediately sought to get the animal to a hospital

My uncle Arley, when I was boy, shot a dog that played too rough with the kids one day.
Please don't take this wrong Rich, but your uncle is an idiot in the same class as Ms Davidson
 
My uncle Arley, when I was boy, shot a dog that played too rough with the kids one day. Said he wouldn't have a dog on the place that would harm a person without cause or reason.

What does "play too rough" mean?
A. The dog was biting the kids.
B. The dog was PLAYING with them, but the dog was just stronger and got the best of the PLAY fight?

If it was B. then I have to agree with joab.
 
My uncle Arley, when I was boy, shot a dog that played too rough with the kids one day.:scrutiny:

Remind me to knock off the horseplay when I'm around your Uncle.


Great, just one more bad rap for the Pits. I own a black pit bull. He's not an Evil Black Assault Pit. He's fully legal, too. He's had his "Auto Sears" removed, so everyone can relax.
 
Cosmoline wrote,
Unless it is an EMERGENCY do not call 911--EVER! It's not only illegal, it may bring a much more serious reaction from local cops than you expect.


very, good advice.
 
Joab said,
Please don't take this wrong Rich, but your uncle is an idiot in the same class as Ms Davidson

You just called the mans uncle an idiot. How would you expect him to "take it"?
 
The officer had every right to enter the premises. If you call 911 they have no way of knowing wether the dispute turned into an assault and one party was laying on the floor bleeding. if she called 911 she should have put the dogs in a room and closed the door.

Please read the article again. The "lady" did lock the dogs in the house while she was in the back yard with the first officer that arrived. Apparently no one bothers to read the article these days.

Another deputy, John Park, was already at Davidson’s mobile home in Riverbend Estates when Steinbach arrived. Park had gone behind the mobile home to deal with a dispute between Davidson and another woman, which is why Davidson called 911.

Steinbach reported he was looking for Park when he went through Davidson’s garage door, knocked on a door to the home and, eventually, opened the door to call for Park. When there was no answer, Steinbach reported he shut the door and that’s when the dogs entered the garage.

Sounds to me like a little officer to officer communication was in order. If either officer had bothered to communicate what was going on then this certainly would have turned out a lot better.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top