I'm torn about shooting my mint condition S&W 17-4, tell me it's ok!

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have a couple of old Smiths (28-2 and 14-3) that are very lightly used. I bought them because they are not made like that anymore and I personally find it satisfying to have a 45 year old firearm in that condition. Hence they get taken out very little.

But I have many other guns to shoot and I am content to let those two stay virtually pristine.

To state the obvious, it's entirely fine to shoot them, I just choose not to with these 2.
 
Fuff, I follow what you're saying. :)

In my experience the 'horse trading' is half the fun. Why else go to gun shows if not to dicker around and try to come home with better stuff? In fact, one of my best trades involved a NIB Beretta shotgun. I have no intention of ever cleaning an autoloading scattergun, but it was on clearance at my LGS; I had some gift cards and was able to get the thing for a song. After swapping it for an AR10, then turning that into a pile of cash, I spent the proceeds on an OD Glock. Basically it turned into a free pistol with the original Beretta money back in my pocket...

My wife says if I could do that on a monthly basis, I could quit my day job. Too bad it doesn't happen like that on a regular basis! :p
 
Rodentman, do you have a Korth that sees regular range usage? I understand those are 'nicer than a python'. Is it true?
 
For a gun that's basically mint condition that has the resale value of a Smith, I probably wouldn't shoot it. Unless I inherit it, I buy guns to shoot them. Every gun I have is meant to be used, not stared at like it's the Freshman high school cheerleader that had a summer growth spurt.

This is why I generally avoid Smith's and Colt's.
 
No I don't have a Korth; that tag line is just a saying I thought was funny. I've been a fool for lesser things, but not sure I'd spend that much on a firearm, even if I could find one.
 
"This is why I generally avoid Smith's and Colt's."

I understand...why spend the money for a firearm...that someone might inherit and cherish...cheap is the way to go....
 
Last edited:
You won't live long enough for a 17 to be worth more in cash than what it's worth in fun to shoot.
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by CajunBass View Post
I used to worry over this myself. My wife finally to told me, "When you're dead either the kids will shoot it, or they'll sell it to someone else who's going to shoot it. Might as well be you."

Made sense to me.
This reply makes the most sense so far to me!

Another Ditto!
 
it has never been fired!

Said the polite salesman at Potomac Arms in Alexandria Virginia as I drooled over a Smith and Wesson model 25-5 125th anniversary edition N frame...

"And it will remain so until I make to Gilbert's" Said I while pulling out cash and identification...

Never regretted it for a minute. Unfired guns are for museums and sick people. Mostly sick people because a fired gun in a museum is more interesting, might have a story..
 
Said the polite salesman at Potomac Arms in Alexandria Virginia as I drooled over a Smith and Wesson model 25-5 125th anniversary edition N frame...

"And it will remain so until I make to Gilbert's" Said I while pulling out cash and identification...

Never regretted it for a minute. Unfired guns are for museums and sick people. Mostly sick people because a fired gun in a museum is more interesting, might have a story..

To each his own. I guess I'm sick. I have a number of un-fired guns. I attach no significant value to just going out and shoot it for the sake of shooting it when I have others that are shot and will continue to be shot.

My suggestion to the OP is to follow your heart. The answer may well be in getting another Model 17 or a new 617 and shoot them.

I also attach no significance to being able to give a family member one of my firearms as in inheritance. My sense is that most would sell them if they could. That feeds into the argument to shoot them or to sell off your collections before there are inheritance issues in your life. Keep a few for posterity.
 
I agree with the rest of the guys. It's a gun which just begs to be enjoyed. And being a .22 caliber in a frame that is built to resist even .357Magnums you will not produce any wear of any consequence regardless of how much you SHOOT IT.

Looks like I'm going to be enjoying it and shooting it as often as I can while taking care of it after every range trip.

Don't just take care of it AFTER the range trip. Proper care is an around the clock situation that starts with proper storage that resists rust and extends to proper handling from the moment you pick up the gun and pack it up for a range visit.

Keeping it in good condition means you take along a hand towel or similar to lay it on while at the range. I've seen some nasty stuff embedded in the mats or wood tables at the ranges I've been at. I tend to not set any of my guns down directly on them. And for those ranges where you'll be putting your guns down on any concrete it goes without saying that you want to bring along a mat of some form of your own.

I prefer towels because I can wash them more frequently than a lot of other options. The back side picks up the grit you're trying to avoid so any mat or towel you use needs to be able to be washed frequently.

So a hand towel for handguns or an old bath towel for rifles goes with me to the range each time.

One thing you will also need for your 17 is a .22 bore brush on a short extension to use to clean out the cylinder chambers part way through a longer session. The chambers are snug on these guns. It's part of what give them their accuracy. I find that the ammo gets hard to load and eject after around 40 to 50 rounds through the gun. A pass with the bore brush restores easy loading and ejecting for another 40 to 50 rounds.

The cheap bulk box ammo will also tend to stick in the chambers sooner than properly packaged ammo. And generally the properly packaged ammo shoots better too since the bullets don't get banged around and become loose in the casings.

You want to exercise great care in cleaning the bore when you do clean it. A rod with a crown protector is a must. If the rod skips off the rifling at the crown your accuracy will suffer in time. A brass or plastic cone shaped protector on the rod does a lot towards avoiding this issue.

I also tend to prefer using a proper sized .22 patch jag and cloth patches and only use a bore brush on the barrel if I see any signs of dullness in the steps of the lands which indicates some lead in there. If the rifling steps are clean and sharp after a cloth patch or two then the bore brush does not get used.
 
I do contest the idea that all guns, without exception, absolutely must be taken out and fired! It's a moral imperative to do so, and a sin if you don't.
This ain't about ALL guns. This is about a Bangor-Punta era S&W model 17. What I contest is this notion that some guns are "too nice" to use. That the premise of saving a couple hundred bucks makes it worthwhile to deny yourself the pleasure of using your own property. Or that "saving" a minty specimen with no appreciable collector value benefits the present owner, only future owners and potential buyers.


In my book that's a decision that should be left to the gun owner.
NO argument there.
 
I have a 17-3 and 1939' pre K22 that go to the range when I'm in the mood to shoot something beautiful.. Occasional hooting won't devalue your revolver as long as you take good care of it while it's in use. That said, if you want to "pound" a revolver with holstering and or rough and frequent use, then a 617 would be a better choice.
 
Your 17 is worth what my 617 cost me new about 4 months ago, I use mine to teach my kid how to shoot, that experience alone is just priceless, and who cares about a little possible wear, you are never going to break one of these guns. There is nothing better than shooting with a nice K frame 22LR revolver!
 
I understand both sides. If it would be worth it to you to spend the $500 or so it would cost to get another good double action revolver to take the load, and you can afford that, then fine.


Is there someone specific in mind you are saving this gun for besides yourself? Because if not, that cherished .22 revolver that means so much to you could get sold for peanuts after you're gone. I always try to keep that in mind. Your gun won't be worth any less with 100 or 1000 rounds through it, and it sounds like you aren't selling anyway. So if it was me, I would probably go ahead and shoot. But that is just my take.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top