No one has asked this yet, so I will:
How in the world did you get to a 500 count without knowing something was wrong?
It's a good practice to check OAL at intervals while loading large batches. I like to give every 50th one a quick mic looksee to be sure the seater hasn't moved, or there isn't any gunk building up in the seater cavity. It does happen.
But if even the first one is 1.18" instead of the 1.14" you wanted - well, something has to be changed in your routine.
Since you said, "They still guage well and fit in the mags and chambers.", I wouldn't bother seating them deeper since I assume they are already taper crimped since you'll end up with a small ring of lead to be removed. Just shoot one or two to see how they are, and then shoot the remainder if all is well.