The SUV loving non-gunny will have to face that his/her SUV is not safe for other people on the road and he/she faces a choice. Do we ban SUVs for the “good” of society, and save as many people as are murdered with guns, or do we let freedom ring and accept that some people will die?
I'm going to warn everyone that I am about to sound like a cold-hearted SOB right now. I don't mean to offend and I am not attacking anyone. I'm just tossing out a viewpoint.
I'd answer that we gain an understanding that life has a 100% chance of death. It's gonna happen-- no matter how hard we try to remove every possible cause.
Driving isn't safe. Driving requires obeying the rules of the road and being aware. Over my years, I've seen more and more people engaging in tailgating, or passing and whipping back in right in front of others. I sometimes think we've seen too many NASCAR commercials and are trying to live out a Jeff Gordon fantasy in our daily commute. "Dude, I'm not tailgating, I'm drafting." Sure you are, scooter.
My point is that things happen. I see a lot of accidents involving 18 wheelers. In fact, two months ago one of my old high school best friends was killed by one in a head-on collision less than 2 miles from my home. I don't see a ban on semi's coming anytime soon.
So, someone wants to drive a car that is highly economical, but has no mass to it, no clearance, and no rigidity. It'll pop like a grape if it gets hit on the interstate. Then the answer is ALWAYS taking action that will cause a change or effort in someone ELSES life. That's the essence of the "ME" generation. "I want it-- so you do everything to make it better for me."
Here's an idea: Put extreme pressure on the automobile industry to create a strong, safe, and economical vehicle that may actually protect you in an accident. We can put a man on the moon... I don't see why that is so hard to envision. We can make a Nascar race car that can hit the wall 6 times, blow all four tires, flip 38 times, catch on fire, blow up, and still have the driver swagger out and wave at the crowd. I think we can do better in bringing up the bar on safety.
This same phenomena is going on in the SUV market with fuel consumption. Already, there have been efforts to make them more fuel effecient-- with a number of hybrids in production or in the works. Why? Because there is a demand for it. Demand that you get your safe little cars. Economics is a strong motivation for innovation.
Perhaps there isn't demand. I find that people often scream for others to be like them or ban thier things when they do not have the numbers or voice to demand change with thier economic force. So they start screaming for legislation. Its not wonder that we are a country dictated to by small special interest groups....
For the public good... lets see... where have I heard that before? Well, I saw it asserted by a Fox news guest who doesn't want anyone eating fast food. I saw it said by someone that doesn't want us eating meat. I saw numerous people say it about banning guns after the VT shootings. I think Stalin, Hitler, Mao, and countless others have used that as well.
-- John