Need some opinions on 10mm 1911s

Status
Not open for further replies.

amusthj

Member
Joined
Aug 25, 2005
Messages
19
Location
West Michigan
I'm looking for a production grade 10mm 1911. All I can find is a Kimber and and Dan Wesson. Am I missing anyone else?

Between Kimber and Dan Wesson, who would get your nod and why?

Thanks
 
If you're not familiar with the 1911 type, maybe you should shoot a standard 45 ACP version to see if you like it before stepping up to a 10mm, which is a high intensity cartridge. The Colt 10mm Auto is also a good choice, if you want to get into a 1911 type. HTH
 
I don't know of anyone else who makes a 10mm in a 1911, heck, I didn't even know Dan Wesson made one, but out of those two I would take the Kimber. They make a sweet .45 so I can imagine that their 10mm couldn't be far behind. If you were willing to look outside the 1911 box; I'd go with the EAA Tanfoglio Witness in 10mm.
 
I have owned five Dan Wesson 10mm 1911s. None of them worked out of the box. All needed from minor to major work to get them running, and DW was no help. I had one Kimber 10mm and it was fine. Hardly a good sample of Kimbers, but I would argue that my DW sampling would be hard to match. Five out of Five guns, 100% failure out of the box.

I love 10mm so often go to extremes to get guns that I want. The least problematic of the DWs was a PM10 that I later sold. My smith had easily corrected its issues, and the present owner reports he is very happy with it. So when I recently saw a PM10 on Guns America cheap I grabbed it. Despite being severely burned by DW, I saw it as a good base gun for further customization. I expected it not to run and that is what I got. For $650, a pistol that would not feed but should be easy to fix. It was actually pretty funny. I went to my smith's to pick it up and we ran out back to his range. He loaded up a mag and started shooting. I stood by expecting failure. Sure enough on round 2 an FTF. He cleared and the same thing happened on round 3. He had to hand cycle/clear his way through the rest of the mag. Rounds hung on the chamber mouth or on the breech face. No biggie. Some polishing and it should be good to go. The previous PM10 was shipped with the wrong length ejector and an extractor that had not been tuned. This one seems better.

So my advice is get the Kimber or look closely at Tanfoglios. Of course one cannot fault a Glock 20 for reliability if you like Glocks. Consider DW only if you are willing to throw further money at it. I would not pay full price as they are going way to high right now. I cannot believe it when I see someone pay over $900 for them on Gunbroker. They will be out a bunch of money if they have to do major work getting the guns to run.

GR
 
DW changed owners. AGAIN.
I have 2 10mm dan wessons, and am happy with them both, but I'm not sure about how the new owners (CZ) are now.
 
Grayrider, sorry to hear of your bad experiences with DW. I have a Patriot C-BOB in 10mm and it has been absolutely flawless since it came out of the box. I've put thousands of rounds through it without a problem. I received it shortly before DW sold out to CZ. I know that DW had problems a few years back but my understanding was that they had worked out all the bugs. More in-depth info on DW and their history and quality can be found here: http://forum.m1911.org/forumdisplay.php?f=34

I'm a huge fan of CZ and with them now running DW I believe that quality will not be an issue. Good luck on your choice.
 
Dan Wesson makes a CBOB, Pointman 7, and RZ in 10mm.
Kimber makes a Stainless Target II and Eclipse Custom II in 10mm.

I've had nothing but good luck with my Kimber Eclipse Custom II in 10mm.

It's probably one of my favorite 10's to shoot.

eclipse10mm.jpg
 
I am sorry some others have had bad experiences with Dan Wesson. I have owned four, currently have three and they were nothing short of perfect out of the box. Two of the three I currently own are 10mm and I love them both. Only one I need now is a dan Wesson Razorback to round out the collection. I also have heard nothing but great things about their current custumer service.

I have no opinion on the Kimber as I don't like them and will probably never own one.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top