Interesting discussion about the 4th amendment and handing over firearms.
When you are pulled over on the side of the road and the officer asks if you are armed or you hand him your CHL, and he asks for said firearm, you've just pulled the firearm into a visible realm, if not completely relinquished it to the LEO. In other words, it falls under the same category as spotting the open beer bottle in the cup holder or the bloody rag, or the bong, or what ever in plain view. It is within the officer's discretion to obtain such items if he feels they may be relevant to a crime or actually criminal. It is NOT unreasonable search and seizure (by letter of law) if YOU hand him the firearm or it's laying in the seat next to you when he pulls you over. As for running the serial, well, you did just give possession, if only temporarily, of the firearm to the LEO, at which point, legally it is fair game for search of the firearm for anything illegal.
A lot of this goes to your attitude towards the officer as well. Which do you feel more threatened by, a guy who greets you nicely on the sidewalk, or some guy who treats you like <
deleted>? So which do you think is more likely to be disarmed? Having said that, I don't blame officers for asking for firearms, it IS a safety issue. It's the same reason that an officer can pull you from a car and search the cabin of the car for weapons if they feel threatened and can articulate that in court. It's the same reason an officer can stop and frisk you. Mind you, a frisk can not be used to search for other items, only weapons or items which could be used as one effectively.
By letter of law, none of that is unreasonable search (and seizure if it turns up anything) to anyone but YOU. It would stand in court, especially if you hand the firearm over to the LEO in the first place.
As for the issue of handing it over and accidental/negligent discharges, sure, but it's fairly easy to drop the magazine, rack the slide with hand over port to catch said ejecting round, and rack it a few more times to ensure it is clear from the officers stand point. I'm not saying every officer can do this, but handguns are not some sort of voodoo magic, their controls are pretty much laid out in a standard configuration for any defense carry firearm. Some education and application to and by officers can go a long way in helping with some of the issues, but for the most part it is fairly standard across the board. I personally would be more worried about the LEO putting my firearm on the hood or roof of my car and scratching the paint (2009 Mustang GT
). Thankfully all of the local LEO's tend to come from a very gun friendly state and most have had more than just their academy and annual qualifications as firearm training.
And on the issue of fumbling a firearm. A lot goes on physiologically in a traffic stop. Any officer who tells you that there is a routine stop is lying to you, and any officer who actually believes that puts himself at serious risk. Adrenaline (yeah, even from a traffic stop), unknown demeanor of the person you just pulled over, location of the stop, etc, all play into exaggerating anxiety which can make it very interesting to handle firearms. Me personally, if I ever get into this situation I would probably do the following:
1. Turn off Car, take keys out and put them on the dash in front of the steering wheel, caution lights and parking break
2. Roll down window and greet officers in a positive (as positive as one can be I guess
) manor.
3. Inform officer that there is a loaded firearm on my person.
4. If officer asks to temporarily confiscate it, inform him that it would make you more comfortable to unload it for him for safety reasons. Heck, tell him that you are a 100% believer that you should never pass a loaded firearm to another person due to the extreme danger that lies in doing so. Then tell him "I will unload the firearm, first by pointing it at the passenger side foot well, dropping the magazine, racking the slide, then racking the slide 2 more times to ensure clear, then I will hand over the firearm." All the while keeping hands in plain view. I would then tell the officer, again, step by step what I'm doing, ensuring to keep hands in plain view as well as the firearm and make your intentions extremely clear that you have zero intent on harming him or his fellow officers.
5. Hand over the firearm first, magazine and ejected round last.
At this point, most officers I have met will have very little issues with letting you unload the firearm, although there will be those who still wish to do it. At which point I will ask again and explain in detail why I wish to clear my firearm. If they are still adamant about it, then I would ask that the LEO not take or attempt to take control of the firearm until it is out of the vehicle and in a safe direction for both our safety's sake.
Sometimes it goes a long way to be respectful and apply logic rather than emotion to your actions. Most officers will respond positively to sound logic rather than irrational fear or extreme attitude about the situation.