S&W- I just do not know... How much would you pay?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah, we've seen this before - but not that much $$. It's the weird cult of the 3" K-frame. They are nice, but they just aren't that rare or that much better than a 2 1/2" or 4".

You just don't question things when the cult is that strong. I have seen these do about $750 in that condition, but $1100 is a bit out of the park.
 
Factory 3 Inch Barrels are rare...but, demand is also...so, seems to me it should be a wash...
 
It's a gorgeous gun, and to some people that kind of money is nothing. Just throw a wad at it and there's little danger of last minute outbidding.

The S&Ws you buy today look like crap. This gun has flash chromed hammer and trigger and the finish is great.

If I were filthy rich, I'd probably drop a grand without a thought.

In two years you most likely won't be able to buy any handgun for less than a grand.
 
I don't remember that 3" 66s were produced in very high numbers. Based on what comes up for sale on the used market, the 3" 65's seem to have been produced in greater numbers than the 66's.


What you're seeing there is the premium collector's place on more unusual or less produced variations.
 
I agree that it is sweet piece! The older Smiths are certainly much more attractive than the present offerings- Makes me wonder what a 3" mint no-dash would go for!

Over the last six months I have been thinking more and more that the pre-97 guns are going to go the rout of the Colt snake guns (price wise) Those older Smiths, especially the pinned and recessed ones in Excellent grade or better will be a diminishing population as the consumer desire for them grows-

I have been snatching up as many nice SS K-frames as I can afford- even paying a post Obama price for one... fairly confident I will be vindicated in the near future :) I prefer 3 and 4" guns but am one of those nuts that goes bananas for a nice 3" Heavy :)

Unfortunately for me I drank Oro and Old Fuff's kool-aid for long-action Smiths... those are going to be prize pieces!

My most recent aquisition was 27-2 8 3/8" with presentation case for $475 It is not as perfect as S&Wfan's but still nice- oh- the group it shot... I should have taken pictures
 
Last edited:
I was only 19 when this one was made, so I couldn't have purchased it then for the going rate of about $170.

Fast forward to 2010. This like new "Cadillac" version of the .357 came available, and I love the 3-3 1/2" S&W revolvers. I paid almost five times that price this year . . . but it was still a decent price . . . and less than a new Model 27 "Classic" sold for last year with the damn lock on the side and the cheesy CNC-cut stocks.

This one is gorgeous . . . and they ain't making pinned and recessed, non-MIM part, checkered topstrap Model 27s anymore. Nor are they numbering the stocks to the gun either . . . and this one has its gorgeous original Magna stocks on it!

So, I got it for more than any other Smith I've ever purchased . . . but less than a good, premium quality 1911.

With good specimens there's a saying . . . "You can never buy a good, vintage S&W revolver and pay too much . . . although you may have purchased it a year or two "early!"

In any event, I've extremely happy with this gorgeous, bright nickle-plated gem! I DO scratch my head a little on that NIB M66 3" . . . but then again, they ain't making those anymore either.

2438196IMG1130pi2a.jpg

2439045IMG1202pw2t.jpg

2438198IMG1136i2a.jpg
 
Last edited:
Unfortunately for me I drank Oro and Old Fuff's kool-aid for long-action Smiths... those are going to be prize pieces!

Trivia note: the first time that I fired one of my long-actions Victories,it did a one-hole group. It was actually in your range about two years ago. So your range has some good karma for those guns...
 
That would be about a $700 gun around these parts on a good day.


Very nice example, but I'd have to say $1100 was "all the money +" for that one.
 
"The older Smiths are certainly much more attractive than the present offerings- Makes me wonder what a 3" mint no-dash would go for!"

5 figures at least. No one has seen one-yet. Joe
 
3" NIB. That's why I own a 3" Taurus 66. Hey, I got a great carry for 180 bucks. I wanted a 3" gun and I'm not a billionaire. Plus, I'm told I have no class. I'm fine with that. Class is over-rated. The pursuit of it is what gets people in credit card trouble. Ain't worth filing bankruptcy over IMHO.

Anyway, a gun is worth what the buyer will pay for it and there's lots of rich buyers to whom 1000 dollars is what they stick in a nice dancer's G string or idiot buyers out there with campaign tastes and beer pocketbooks.
 
I don't remember that 3" 66s were produced in very high numbers. Based on what comes up for sale on the used market, the 3" 65's seem to have been produced in greater numbers than the 66's.

3" 66s weren't produced in as great a numbers as 2.5", 4" and 6" varieties, and I think you are also right about 3" 65s being more common than 3" 66s.

I've never actually seen a 3" 66 in person. $650-ish seems to be the market value for these guns today. 2.5 inchers routinely sell for $550-$600 where I live as well.

But almost $1100, even with the box and papers? Eek, looking at the bid history, that buyer had a major itch to scratch and pile of money I suppose. If I were the seller, I'd be laughing all the way to the bank. You can buy a freakin' Colt Python for that kind of money.

I'll admit to slighly overpaying for a 3" Model 13-3 in 98-99% condition with the original box and papers for $450 a few months ago. I too had an itch, but not as severe as the one experienced by the buyer of that 3" 66. But watching gunbroker and reports online, it seems that these guns (3" 13s and 65s) are rapidly increasing in price too.

As I side note, I've always been puzzled why 3" 13s and 65s sell for so much less than 3" 19s and 66s (respectively). The only difference are the fixed sights and no ejector rod shroud on the 13 and 65. Maybe it is because the 3" 13s and 65s are a little more common? That's a relative term though, as I've only seen one 3" K Frame 357 in 3 years in all the shops and gun shows I've been to: the one I bought. I did miss out on a 90% or so example 2 years ago for $275.

Over the last six months I have been thinking more and more that the pre-97 guns are going to go the rout of the Colt snake guns (price wise) Those older Smiths, especially the pinned and recessed ones in Excellent grade or better will be a diminishing population as the consumer desire for them grows-

I believe you are correct. I've seen a few model 27s and 29s starting to kiss the 4 figure mark now.

3" NIB. That's why I own a 3" Taurus 66. Hey, I got a great carry for 180 bucks. I wanted a 3" gun and I'm not a billionaire.

I'd pay $180 in a hearbeat for such a gun, and I'd still buy it for as much as $300 today. Funny thing, used Taurus 66s always have asking prices higher than new ones in my area (same can be said for Ruger Single Sixes). In fact, used Taurus 66s are priced about the same as S&W 66s. :scrutiny:

I guess people in my area are buying them for these prices. Yes, I actually saw someone pay $450 for a beat-to-crap Taurus 66 4" not long ago at a gunshow :eek: . I saw a 2.5" Taurus 66 (blued) that was in great condition at the same show, but it was priced at $425, IIRC. This was a little over 1 year ago.
 
Last edited:
I'd pay $180 in a hearbeat for such a gun, and I'd still buy it for as much as $300 today. Funny thing, used Taurus 66s sell always have asking prices higher than new ones. In fact, used Taurus 66s are priced about the same as S&W 66s.

I guess people in my area are buying them for these prices. Yes, I actually saw someone pay $450 for a beat-to-crap Taurus 66 4" not long ago

I bought mine at a gun show about 3 years ago. This gun show, in particular, is not noted for bargains. It's small. But, Taurus simply doesn't bring the prices around here in Smith and Wesson country. Even Rugers don't go for THAT much. Smiths are outrageous and a 1000 dollar 3" 66 is not surprising to me. The guy must be from coastal Texas.

So, sounds like a good scheme to buy up all the Taurus 66s in my area and drive to Florida to sell 'em at a gun show. :D
 
Unfortunately for me I drank Oro and Old Fuff's kool-aid for long-action Smiths... those are going to be prize pieces!

Generally speaking, K-frame S&W revolvers with the old “long action” are not overpriced unless they are, or are close to, like new condition. That’s because a lot of them were made, buyers are generally not interested – unless the barrel length is 2-inches. Those that have 5 or 6 inch barrels often go begging. N-frame guns are another matter.

What shooters who are knowledgeable look for is the relative few that were made shortly after World War Two and have the current style hammer block that makes them unquestionably safe to carry fully loaded with 6 rounds.

Most collectors couldn’t care less about this. In addition most sellers – including dealers – don’t know about the difference either. So if they are in perfect mechanical shape with clean chambers and bores, but noticeable finish wear that should be expected, they will be priced at $300 or less – and sometimes much less.

And since .38 Special revolvers (other then snubbies) are out of favor an “informed buyer” can sometimes dicker the asking price in a downward direction. :evil:

It’s all a matter of knowing what to look for. ;)
 
I sold my 3" 66 F-comp for about $800.
I traded my 3" 65LS straight up for a 6906.
I don't miss those guns very much. A 2.5" model 19 or 66 is just as good, and cost 60% of the price.
 
Well that IS a LNIB 66 with a 3" barrel......I don't think I'd go quite that high....but then I already own one.

When you compare that 3" 66 to the latest junk revolvers coming out of Springfield MA, and the asking price for that......stuff, it doesn't appear that unreasonable, to me. TJ
 
I just borrowed my dads S&W 66-1 with a 3 inch bbl, and all I can say is wow!! I had no idea that it was worth that much and you can definately can see the quality of the older Smiths when holding it. I am half tempted to trade him my 686+ to get the 66-1, but I doubt he will go for it. Can't hurt to try!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top