No problem with that here. In my mind, every task should have the best tool available at hand. I never bought a revolver with the consideration of pressing it into SD duty... I'm not a revolver guy, per se. I didn't buy my 1911's entirely with the purpose of tasking them into SD duty, although I do occasionally... and particularly my alloy 4", which I actually bought with a 50/50 SD/range purpose. I DID buy my Kahr 9mm's specifically for SD... they really aren't intended for anything else.
Back Home, Years Ago, I used to buy JHP's for some of my reloading... which in hindsight was sort of stupid. I don't hunt. At the time, I didn't carry (it was not legal where I was, back when I cared.) So maybe I had some stupid idea of using a 6" .41MAG as a home defense weapon...? I quit buying jacketed bullets, and my recreational guns shoot, largely, cast bullets, now.
Everyone has their own idea of an SD weapon, and their reasonings for such, to include how they carry them, the ammunition they are stoked with, and their training and tactics mindset. I've read some threads here and have scratched my head a time or two, and very likely someone has read my nonsense and done the very same thing. Conversely, I've read some threads and thought they were touched with brilliance... and only because it mirrored what I think or believe.
But at the end of the day, every firearm is a firearm. I wouldn't really want to go skeet shooting with a Mossberg 590... but it'll do it. Flip the coin... and I wouldn't really want to use a break action trap gun for home defense... but if it was all I had, it's better than a rock.
Years ago, one could read many months worth of a gun rag without seeing any article about guns with a primary usage for SD. It was all about hunting and recreation. Now, you're lucky to find one article at all in those same rags about hunting and/or recreation.
+1
Firearms for hunting and sport have relatively remain unchanged in so many years... minus new cartridges and updated firearms (think poly, adjustable stocks, etc.) We have come a very long way, however, from a 4" S&W model 10, or Chiefs Special in .38SPC for defense, primarily driven, I believe, by the marketplace... and for two reasons: 1) The expansion of states allowing concealed or open carry, and 2) the rise in violent crime. Those two items created a void in the market that the manufacturers rushed to fill... and that is where the market is, today.