PowderKeg
Member
I've been looking into getting a gun safe and have pretty much narrowed down the choices to either a Sturdy Safe 2723 (60x27x23”deep) or a Browning Copper series (60x30x25”deep), both firelined. The Browning uses gypsum/fireboard, and the Sturdy uses a combination of ceramic and fiberglass wool insulation and a steel inner liner. The Browning is “rated” at 45 minutes; the Sturdy is not “rated” but does have an interesting testimonial/description of a total burndown on their website, as well as a lengthy discussion about firelining materials. Both lose @ 4” for interior width and weigh about the same (630 vs 615 lbs). Positives for the Sturdy include the 8 guage body, 1/4” door plate, and a simpler and theoretically more robust locking system. The Browning has a 12 guage body and 3/16” door plate, but is 3” wider on the inside. I'm also a little partial to the more open Sturdy #2 interior (customizing possibilities). The Browning is roughly $175 cheaper from the local Sportsman's Warehouse - both would have to be picked up (Browning at SW, Sturdy at the local shipper's dock).
http://www.sturdysafe.com/minuteman.htm
http://www.browning.com/products/catalog/safes/detail.asp?cat_id=160&type_id=42736&value=002F
Right now I'm leaning heavily towards to Sturdy Safe, but I'd like to hear some comments about them from owners. Anyone have experience with Sturdy? Even better, someone with fire or burglary attempt experiences? Interested in opinions on the Browning too.
http://www.sturdysafe.com/minuteman.htm
http://www.browning.com/products/catalog/safes/detail.asp?cat_id=160&type_id=42736&value=002F
Right now I'm leaning heavily towards to Sturdy Safe, but I'd like to hear some comments about them from owners. Anyone have experience with Sturdy? Even better, someone with fire or burglary attempt experiences? Interested in opinions on the Browning too.