Are there really as many sub-MOA shooters out there as you would believe by reading forum posts?
If I were to take as gospel all of the various posts that I read, then we have a sport/hobby filled with marksmen who are sub-MOA shooters all day, every day. Really.......?
So, what are the criteria for considering yourself a sub-MOA rifleman? How many groups out of how many shot? How many shots per group etc? What about flyers or sighters?
Let's face it - a lot of what is posted to a forum concerning group size is exaggerated. There is no accountability. Anyone can shoot one-holers at 25yds and post them to a forum claiming they were shot at 100yds or more. (We all know some are real from regular, contributing members, but many are exaggerated also.) On top of that, if anyone who garishly flaunts their incredible shooting ability is actually invited to a range even for practice, they never show.
There are not as many sub-MOA shooters as the internet would have you believe, but there are many great shooters that use forums. I suppose that it doesn't help that manufacturers have advertised rifles with 1MOA guarantees - that means that everyone who owns one is a 1MOA shooter, right
One of the telltale signs of the keyboard marksman are those iconic words, "subMOA all day, IF I do my part." It makes me wonder how often they do not do their part. It also makes me wonder how many shots were made "all day."
The point about bench shooting vs field shooting is absolutely correct - there are more things in motion in the field. Game does not usually stand still and I've yet to see an orange dot on the kill zone of a prairie dog, groundhog, squirrel, rabbit, or deer.
In terms of attaining a title - I don't care, it doesn't matter that much - the most important thing to me is in my sig line.
I was recently shooting a nothing special AR, with an aftermarket trigger. Benched, shooting bag rest, no rear bag, scope set on 9x. I keep a potpourri box of 223 ammo with some of my best loads for testing - different bullet weights and loads 50-75gr to see what a rifle likes, but all mag length or less. Twelve groups of five later, four of those groups are subMOA and a few are just over. Many AR's are relatively easy to get to shoot well compared with large rifle calibers.
To me, three shots means very little. I prefer to start with at least two groups of five. Groups of ten get tricky as concentration and endurance become more of an issue. In contrast, a typical big game hunter just needs one cold barrel shot to hit the target to call it a success.
IMO sighters are fine - they get you on target and warm up the barrel. It's just that flyers should count toward the group. If a flyer messed up the group, then shoot another group. "Flyer" sounds so much better than "shooter error" or "flinch" - it's rarely the fault of the ammo. I just think too many people give themselves too many mulligans in the name of "flyer". Small groups are not easy for field or lightweight rifles as the internet has portrayed. They are easier for more stationary or bench style rifles - heavyweight barrels with a bipod and a too light for hunting trigger.