Used XD 40 & PT 111 G2 Value

[Mike J]

Okay, so I have a couple of guns I am thinking of selling. There is actually a guy at work that is interested in buying so I am trying to figure out what is fair. One is a XD-40 with 3 magazines, the box, all the factory goodies that came with it & a couple of holsters for it. The XD has about 3,000 rounds through it.
The other is a Taurus PT-111 G2, with the box, 2 magazines basically what came with it from the factory & a Safariland GLS holster. Both guns work & have been problem free.
There is another firearm I want & I am thinking of selling both of these to finance the purchase. So what do y'all think would be fair. I am honestly thinking $350 for both pistols, the holsters, magazines etc. Just sell all of it as a package. Do ya'all think this would be fair or is my price off base?

 

[VoodooMountain]

$300 for xd and $200 for Taurus would be going rate in my area

 

[Mike J]

$300 for xd and $200 for Taurus would be going rate in my area

With both of them being used?

 

[VoodooMountain]

With both of them being used?

Yes

 

[Mike J]

Thank You VoodooMountain. I am thinking about selling these 2 & getting a mid-sized .40. I believe it would take the place of both of them just fine.

I just want to find what is fair to both of us.

 

[bannockburn]

Mike J

Just me but I think $350 for both guns and the holsters is a little low. I'm thinking more like somewhere from $450 to $500. Maybe throw in some ammo and call it a deal.

 

[Mike J]

Thanks Y'all. I will talk to him a little later on. I'm probably going to sit on it for a few days. Make my mind up. I had thought about a G-23 but the M&P 2.0 .40 compact is roughly the same size & can be had for around $400 new if one shops around.

 

[Gottcha]

500 for both with the accessories is a fair price for both of you. If it's a good work buddy 450 would be giving him a great deal.

 

[bannockburn]

Gottcha

Yeah, sell them both for $450 and you'll have a good work buddy for life!

 

[Mike J]

They are both good guns. Nothing wrong with them but I am not emotionally attached to either of them & I'm wanting something else. I don't have the cash to just go buy right now so I was thinking this would be a way to get what I want without really sacrificing anything. I'll just end up with one less pistol but I don't really consider either one of them anything special. I may just go back to carrying the old P94 until I pick up the next one.

 

[Tallball]

I don't know squat about the XD.

The Taurus is not worth much. You can get a brand-new one for under $200. The blued are not worth as much as the stainless. I got a brand-new stainless for $217 not long ago (which was admittedly a good deal). They are good pistols, IMHO, but very inexpensive if you hunt around a bit.

 

[Blue Feather]

Mike J

Just me but I think $350 for both guns and the holsters is a little low. I'm thinking more like somewhere from $450 to $500. Maybe throw in some ammo and call it a deal.

I can get either of them brand new flat that price but if the OP can get that for them then more power to him. He should start high though.

 

[Walkalong]

Gotcha

Yeah, sell them both for $450 and you'll have a good work buddy for life!

Have to agree, it's fair to both and he'll appreciate it. Relationships last a lot longer than an extra $50 here or there.

 

[bluzman]

Sold my 2011 vintage XD-40 for $300.

 

[G'dale Mike]

I just tried to trade my Springfield XD subcompact in 40cal at lgs to help the price on a lightly used Ruger precision rifle in 6.5. They wouldn’t even take it on trade. Said that they can’t move anything in 40 cal these days.

 

[Everready73]

G2 would go for about 175 used around here. The Springfield $250-275 so I would go a little higher than _350 but not much. I don't add value for accessories unless it's ammo when I purchased a gun. I probably would never use the stuff someone else bought for it

 

[Styx]

F2F sale, I could sell the G2 on ArmsList for $250-$275. The 40 XD would be a harder sale, but I could sell it for $350. Selling the XD for -$300 private sale is a rip off IMHO.

F2F prices are generally higher. I've sold a few guns on ArmsList. You'll get a few lowballers and some who will tell you they can buy for less elsewhere, but I always end up finding a buyer at asking price.

If you just want to get rid of them, for $350, I'll buy the guns from you w/o the accessories.