What's so great about AR-15's anyway?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think this is less of a caliber question than a platform question...

I have nothing against the .223 round, I do however have questions on why an AR is so expensive, why it feels like a toy when I shoulder it...
 
I have nothing against the .223 round, I do however have questions on why an AR is so expensive, why it feels like a toy when I shoulder it...

Let's see... made in America, not some 3rd world back water, meant to be light weight and easy to handle.... too easy... give us something hard...
 
I know there are plenty of AR-15 fanatics here. But no matter how much I read about accuracy, customization, light-weight, size, and range, I can't figure out what on earth the AR-15 is GOOD for.
I can't think of good use for twinkies and cupcakes either, how about those arcaic blackpowder guns, That 9mm hi capacity pistol doesn't seem to serve any GOOD purpose either. Maybe the same can be said for traps, bows and arrows, and even fish hooks.
 
I do however have questions on why an AR is so expensive, why it feels like a toy when I shoulder it...

Expensive compared to what? You can get a generic AR in the $600-$700 range (momentary panic buying notwithstanding).
Compared to Century AK's made of stamped sheet metal assembled by monkeys? Yeah, it's probably more expensive than that. Not that AK's cannot be made entirely reliable, but a quality AK is going to run in the $1000 range or so. Think Arsenal etc.

As for the feel, it's a very light rifle. If you want something that feels heavy they are out there, mostly with wood stocks. Nothing wrong with that but just because the AR's are light weight doesn't mean much.

They are designed to be carried around, everywhere. Lug one around for several days and you will be grateful for that light weight :)

Don't get me wrong, I'm not an AR fan boy. I prefer things in .308 most of the time, but the AR is a fine design that has stood the test of time better than most. Blowing it off entirely is simply shallow thinking.
 
ARs are actually not that expensive compared to a comparative weapon. AK copies and SKS rifles are cheaper because they are all 50 years+ old or have been built from military surplus parts. ARs are new manufacture built from an aircraft aluminum alloy to high tolerances by American labor.
 
Well ask that question about any firearm. What makes a firearm unique and desirable? Caliber, action type, reloading system, size, shoulderability, pointability, etc. It's all different and usually subjective.

I am undecided on the AR-15. I have a complete lower.

It's not practical for most people to "multi task" like you guys all talk about. I think most shooters don't spend as much on guns than most of the members here and just don't have a need for it.

It can be a hunting rifle, it can be a self defense rifle, it can be a target rifle, it can be a lot of things, but there are a lot more guns that can do the same thing. For example; my Remington 700 is a great hunting rifle. An AR-15 can be just as good of a hunting rifle, but I chose my Remington 700 instead. Why? Because I did. So one reason people like them is just because it's their thing and they dig it.


Also take into consideration the cool factor. I think a lot of young guys who are new into shooting get them. It's also just a cool thing.


Sorry for the lot of unfinished thoughts but I really think a lot of guys like the gun.
 
.308 AR 15 (AR10 actually) bear hunting:
Wayne-Christensen-large.jpg

Remington AR in .243 : remington-r-25-tm.jpg
Walnut if you're into wood : indxlm7wlnt550.jpg
 
Could is be that Americans like to own AR's because...

1) They are the present 'sword' of democracy. Maybe people want to have some connection with the good guys?

2) Millions of service men and women have been trained on the AR platform. Many are not gun enthusiasts (meaning people who like to know alot about a wide variety of weapons). Maybe they just want a weapon for home defense that they feel very comfortable with?

3) The AR has many after market parts and accessories. It's the adult lego. maybe some people just want a hobby of modifying an existing platform?

4) The AR can be hunting, target, home-defense, military, family heirloom weapon. Many critics have debated it's merits in every role. Still, there's a loyal following. What's so wrong with that?

5) Americans have a right to keep and bear arms...and guess what? It doesn't matter if that gun is accompanied by a hunting license or not. So hunting arguments have little merit in the justification of a legal weapon.
 
But ARs just seem so cliche

So you're going off of "feelings" rather than any facts. That's fine, I've bought many firearms off of feelings, but they are not something you can really debate.
 
By not owning one. I would say you are missing out on a lot.
 
They aren't bad target shooters.

They aren't bad survival or home defense weapons, particularly for those having some acreage and multiple buildings/outbuildings and many approaches to defend at distance.

In a survival situation where you travel or otherwise remain on the move and in the field for extended periods, a rifle is better than a pistol. I consider an AK better than an AR for this purpose -- lighter, smaller (especially with folding stock), more rugged -- but some prefer the AR.

And finally, some people buy them for professional reasons having little or nothing to do with the above. Some of us buy them because we occasionally are paid to carry guns and/or train other individuals to use guns, and our clients prefer to see their part-time "bodyguard" with an AR -- more "official" and paramilitary-looking than an AK, to them -- and to be instructed on an "M16". Some buy them because they like to practice with their military issue weapons before or in between periods of active military duty. That's why some of us purchase Beretta 92FS pistols and AR-pattern rifles and carbines, and practice with them using ball ammunition in military shooting positions.
 
All I've heard so far in a nutshell is "if it can't be used to hunt in stock form, then it isn't that useful."

Well, it can't be LEGALLY used to hunt with, but that doesn't stop people with 9mm pistols and .22 rifles from poaching or otherwise hunting illegally. The .223 will drop a deer no problem. Just don't get caught.
 
You still don't understand what you are talking about. You are bringing more than a few dispelled myths out such as the "shotgun racking" idiocy.

I use a shotgun with slugs for HD because I have interior brick walls. If they were normal wood and paper I wood use an AR in .223 with fragmenting bullets. This would be much safer than slugs or buckshot going through my walls.

But what about us who just have regular, Drywall? And the Box O Truth didn't seem to think that 00 Buckshot overpenetrated to much.

I can't think of good use for twinkies and cupcakes either, how about those arcaic blackpowder guns, That 9mm hi capacity pistol doesn't seem to serve any GOOD purpose either. Maybe the same can be said for traps, bows and arrows, and even fish hooks.

Your to angry and... something else to be taken seriously at the moment. Seriously, if I'm living in a society where questions are to be treated with hostility then maybe your the Ivan?

Hunting rifles serve no real useful purpose either. You can buy meat at the grocery store for crying out loud.

Careful, X-Rap probably thinks your a communist by now! :D Hunting is a heck of a lot better than buying meat. You either get fat, at 5.99 a pound from Wally-World or pure lean meat that you killed yourself and processed yourself.

Expensive compared to what? You can get a generic AR in the $600-$700 range (momentary panic buying notwithstanding).
Compared to Century AK's made of stamped sheet metal assembled by monkeys? Yeah, it's probably more expensive than that. Not that AK's cannot be made entirely reliable, but a quality AK is going to run in the $1000 range or so. Think Arsenal etc.

As for the feel, it's a very light rifle. If you want something that feels heavy they are out there, mostly with wood stocks. Nothing wrong with that but just because the AR's are light weight doesn't mean much.

They are designed to be carried around, everywhere. Lug one around for several days and you will be grateful for that light weight

Don't get me wrong, I'm not an AR fan boy. I prefer things in .308 most of the time, but the AR is a fine design that has stood the test of time better than most. Blowing it off entirely is simply shallow thinking.

That's something that AK fans have me questioning. They brag all day long about how they only paid $599 for their Romy AK, but really? It's made with parts deemed unsuitable for the Romanian military. Most other AK's are either knock-offs or decades old hand-me-downs. At $500+ you could probably do better utility-wise with a Mini-30 or a lever-gun.

The light-weight on AR's are nice. Like I said, plenty weigh around 5 pounds (someone makes a 4.5 pound AR I hear?).

And again I'm not trying to hate on the AR, or blow it off. I'm just trying to understand it. If that's to much to ask, then X-Rap is probably frothing mad at the Comy world were living in :rolleyes: .

All I've heard so far in a nutshell is "if it can't be used to hunt in stock form, then it isn't that useful."

Well, it can't be LEGALLY used to hunt with, but that doesn't stop people with 9mm pistols and .22 rifles from poaching or otherwise hunting illegally. The .223 will drop a deer no problem. Just don't get caught.

Yeah, that's not something I think we need to be associating ourselves with... we already get enough hell from anti-gun nuts. We don't need to be advocating something illegal.

yesit'sloaded said:
R 15 (AR10 actually) bear hunting:
Remington AR in .243 :
Walnut if you're into wood :

That's more reasonable. AR-10's and other larger caliber AR's are certainly good hunters. I've never seen a .308 fail to take deer (or bear, or moose, or... well there isn't a lot a .308 can't take down).

And finally, some people buy them for professional reasons having little or nothing to do with the above. Some of us buy them because we occasionally are paid to carry guns and/or train other individuals to use guns, and our clients prefer to see their part-time "bodyguard" with an AR -- more "official" and paramilitary-looking than an AK, to them -- and to be instructed on an "M16". Some buy them because they like to practice with their military issue weapons before or in between periods of active military duty. That's why some of us purchase Beretta 92FS pistols and AR-pattern rifles and carbines, and practice with them using ball ammunition in military shooting positions.

Professionals, even private citizens like body-guards and PMC's, certainly will find a use for an AR-15. Like I said, the 5.56x45 doesn't have problem with people (and walls). If it did, a lot of Iraqis, Vietnamese, and British Troops in North Ireland would be walking around today. And if your walking in the open at the flank of someone, I imagine anyone trying to harm that someone would skip a heartbeat at the sight on an AR-15.

It's the utility, IE non-LEO/Mil/contractor purposes I was having questions about. Two of the guys on page 1 told me what I wanted to know regarding hunting. Apparently the 64 and up bullets are powerful enough to be legal and hence many states reversed their stance on it as a hunting cartridge.
 
guys, this thread is bad enough... let's not let it drift into personal attacks
 
The .223 will drop a deer no problem. Just don't get caught.

Huh? In case you didn't know it hunting with .223/5.56 is legal in many places. Quite ethical too if you choose your ammo and shot properly.
 
Fun, fun, fun! Fun to shoot, fun to modify, fun hobby! It's not breaking my bank so I don't need to justify it's role in my life except for pure enjoyment. I don't use it mine for hunting or HD, only shooting targets and tuning it. Fun Gun!
 
But what about us who just have regular, Drywall? And the Box O Truth didn't seem to think that 00 Buckshot over penetrated to much.

I was talking about wood framed dry wall which is essentially gypsum and paper; but it matters not. Your walls, your family, your call. Keep in mind that the BoT is entertainment not science.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top