Would you own a 300 Win Mag if you didn't hunt? Details inside, I need your opinion

It wasn't a published load, something someone said on the forums. In fact I edited my post to reflect that.

More I think about it, the more I wonder if the 'want' makes it make sense or not. But I don't want another 308 and I don't want to go away from 30 cal I don't think either.
Curious if it's about sharing components? If he has a 308 many good options share cases. My focus was to give you the long range option playing with all other knobs. Do you have a 1k range available? The longest easily available range I have is 200. When I shot with my dad 888 lyds was available. I've never been to a legit 1k range.
 
Curious if it's about sharing components? If he has a 308 many good options share cases. My focus was to give you the long range option playing with all other knobs. Do you have a 1k range available? The longest easily available range I have is 200. When I shot with my dad 888 lyds was available. I've never been to a legit 1k range.

No, not about sharing components at all. If anything I wouldn't want to sacrifice his 308 for my needs. And this is where we will be shooting https://www.clintonhouse.com/shooting
 
I wonder what the recoil would be comparable to. The most unpleasant thing I've shot would be my Benelli M2 18" with buckshot. Not terrible but it's a decent kick in the shoulder.
The 300 Wby has slightly more case capacity than the 300 Win Mag (98gr H2O vs 91.5gr H2O). The 300 RUM case capacity is 110.2gr H2O. The 30-378 Weatherby Mag can apparently do 120gr H2O.

In my experience, only my 8mm Rem Mag is more unpleasant to shoot (compared to my 300 Wby Mag) from a recoil standpoint.

I've fired a family members 375 H&H and it was more of a firm push; of course it was a heavier rifle overall, which is a factor.
 
Last edited:
I wonder what the recoil would be comparable to. The most unpleasant thing I've shot would be my Benelli M2 18" with buckshot. Not terrible but it's a decent kick in the shoulder.
The m2 stock changes the perceived recoil period. The .300 is snappy and obnoxious like a .243 (recoil velocity) whereas your 12 ga is a slow push comparatively. The .300wm will put out 26ish ft-lbs of raw recoil energy in an 8ish lb rifle, closest comparison that jumps to mind is the 7stw. The .338wm in a hunting rifle is even more obnoxious. I'd hate to tell a fellow his business, but pick a bullet you want to use, then look at the cartridges capable of launching it at the velocity you want to attain... pick the one using the least amount of powder to get there. Essentially, the 300wm will quickly point out flaws in your form and after a couple 20 rds, you'll be ready to let it take a break.... now if you make it heavier, put a suppressor on it...or even a decent brake...it's closer to an 06. My 16 y/o daughter can shoot grandpa's 300rum standing, barrel jumps about a foot and a half, but she finds it tolerable....we haven't tried it in any sort of benched or prone setting, and probably never will. Just stuff to think about.
 
A couple of my long range shooting buddies have a couple custom 300 Winmags. Those guns really shine with 210+ grain bullets. They also shoot a lot of 308, 223, and 6.5CM out past 1000 yards regularly and even a mile several times a year. While those rounds all get there, the 300s do it far easier.
 
For punching paper at long range it's hard to beat 6.5 CM. You get virtually the same trajectory as 300 WM way past 1000 yards with 1/2 the recoil and 1/2 the cost whether you reload or buy off the shelf ammo. If you do decide to hunt with it, it'll kill anything a 270 will kill at the same ranges.

I've never seen a 6.5 CM that wasn't extremely accurate. The 300 WM hasn't been a contender in long range target shooting in decades. There are simply more accurate cartridges. It is a good choice for hunting larger game such as elk at longer than normal ranges.

The 308 is a fine cartridge, but it starts running out of gas at around 800 yards. With handloads and longer than standard barrels you can squeeze 1000 out of it. For hunting big game it is near ideal for anything in the lower 48 states and is a good target round out to 800-1000 yards.

The 30-06 is a great hunting cartridge but both the 308 and 6.5 CM have proven to be more accurate, recoil much less, and cost less to feed. It only beats 308 by about 100 fps with factory loads. Hot handloads will beat 308 by around 200 fps.

If you're not shooting past 200 yards get a 223. They hold up well enough out to 600 yards and you'll save a lot of money on ammo.
 
No, not about sharing components at all. If anything I wouldn't want to sacrifice his 308 for my needs. And this is where we will be shooting https://www.clintonhouse.com/shooting
If that's where your shooting the mile will be staring you down, just go 338 lapua and be done.... if lr is your flavor... the nightforce beast is your next purchase.
 
If that's where your shooting the mile will be staring you down, just go 338 lapua and be done.... if lr is your flavor... the nightforce beast is your next purchase.

The mile won't be staring us down anytime soon. I've shot factory 308 out of a bolt action and sent 223 out to 300 yards a hand full of times. He's never shot and we both will really be learning long range shooting.
 
I’m guessing if you’re shooting that far, you’ll be on a bench, I feel sorry for your shoulder. I didn’t see any mention of hunting either, so here goes.

Weight is going to be your friend. Fat barrel, 24”-26”, heavy composite stock, big scope, and a squishy thick recoil pad. Think benchrest rifle. Youre wanting long range, accuracy is the deal here. Check our brux, bartlein, etc for barrel blanks. Have action tried up if it’s not already. Ultimately, it’s up to you on what you want to buy.

I have shot a 700 bdl in 300wm, free hand it was ok recoil wise, on the bench, it sucked.
 
Also guys please keep in mind I'm wanting to build a M24 clone which will be a Remington 700 LONG ACTION, which obviously will limit my caliber choices.
Your priorities are starting to come out, which is good. So if your wanting a Remington long action tell me why 280ai isn't you best option. Basically a 7mmwm without the belt and the mag case head. Next would be 7mm prc.
 
Your priorities are starting to come out, which is good. So if your wanting a Remington long action tell me why 280ai isn't you best option. Basically a 7mmwm without the belt and the mag case head. Next would be 7mm prc.

Tell me if this is dumb or not. While I don't care too much for cloning I've always appreciated military rifles. Now while I know a new Remington 700 in any configuration you can buy new isn't a M24, I think getting it close while being a military cartridge is a necessity. Kinda like building a MK18 Mod0 but in a 300 blackout. Not something I'd want to do.

I'll put my pros and worries out on the 300 Win Mag idea

Pros:
ALWAYS wanted a 300 Win Mag due to it's sheer power. Kinda along the lines of modifying your factory Corvette to 900rwhp. You will never need it but you have it.
Military had some in 300 Win Mag however most were 308 LA.
IF I learn 300 Win Mag just isn't something for me, when I rebarrel it I can put a 308 M24 profile barrel in it and that would be an accurate M24 anyways.

Worries:
Will be a powder hog when powder already cost a lot. Cost about 10gr more per trigger pull over 30-06
Recoil will make it a safe queen (I don't think I would let this happen but I've never shot one)
Recoil could make learning long range shooting hard (However again, will have my son's 308 to also shoot)
 
The mile won't be staring us down anytime soon. I've shot factory 308 out of a bolt action and sent 223 out to 300 yards a hand full of times. He's never shot and we both will really be learning long range shooting.
If you put in a little time and have a good mentor, you'll be surprised how quick you'll progress. After reading your comments and replies, I think staying with 300wm or 300prc is still your best bet. 300prc has the advantage when you get to 1000yds or more. At 1000yds the 300wm is gonna have about 30 to 40 inches more drop than the PRC. At 1500yds the difference is about 100 inches.
One caviat though, some 300wm such as my X-bolt have 1/8 twist like the PRC instead of the typical 1/10 in most 300wm. This makes the two much closer as far as trajectory until you get past 1000yds. If you are going to do a custom build, you could have the faster twist and have it throated to better take the heavier bullets like 230gr and have a 300wm that's right on the heels of a PRC.
 
Tell me if this is dumb or not. While I don't care too much for cloning I've always appreciated military rifles. Now while I know a new Remington 700 in any configuration you can buy new isn't a M24, I think getting it close while being a military cartridge is a necessity. Kinda like building a MK18 Mod0 but in a 300 blackout. Not something I'd want to do.

I'll put my pros and worries out on the 300 Win Mag idea

Pros:
ALWAYS wanted a 300 Win Mag due to it's sheer power. Kinda along the lines of modifying your factory Corvette to 900rwhp. You will never need it but you have it.
Military had some in 300 Win Mag however most were 308 LA.

Worries:
Will be a powder hog when powder already cost a lot. Cost about 10gr more per trigger pull over 30-06
Recoil will make it a safe queen (I don't think I would let this happen but I've never shot one)
Recoil could make learning long range shooting hard (However again, will have my son's 308 to also shoot)
In the begging of this I recommended a 6br because recoil is a major factor in accuracy shooting for even experienced shooters. If your learning fundamentals low pain means your attention is paid on things like wind calls, proper hold and good follow through, while being able to watch impact. Heavy hitters are not for practice and learning, they are for results. No high value target needed 50 in the x ring.
 
If you put in a little time and have a good mentor, you'll be surprised how quick you'll progress. After reading your comments and replies, I think staying with 300wm or 300prc is still your best bet. 300prc has the advantage when you get to 1000yds or more. At 1000yds the 300wm is gonna have about 30 to 40 inches more drop than the PRC. At 1500yds the difference is about 100 inches.
One caviat though, some 300wm such as my X-bolt have 1/8 twist like the PRC instead of the typical 1/10 in most 300wm. This makes the two much closer as far as trajectory until you get past 1000yds. If you are going to do a custom build, you could have the faster twist and have it throated to better take the heavier bullets like 230gr and have a 300wm that's right on the heels of a PRC.
I think he is trying to mentor his son.
 
I had a 300 Win Mag, decades ago, in a semi-custom rifle. This amounted to a "blue-printed" Savage action glass bedded into a graphite stock and fitted with a heavy Douglas barrel.

As I recall, the thing was about 12 pounds, so recoil was a non-issue. And of course it was more accurate than I was, which is generally going to be the case for properly-made rifles handled by anyone other than very experienced benchrest shooters. (I don't believe in "accurate" or "inaccurate" cartridges, in general.)

I have no use for such a thing these days, but certainly enjoyed it while I had it, and can recommend it to anyone who expresses an interest. As a thousand-yard "gong ringer" it was just about perfect.
 
Well son and I want to get into long range shooting. I've always loved a Remington 700 and he wants a 308. If you look back at this thread I made about his choice... https://www.thehighroad.org/index.php?threads/best-308-for-600ish.926385/page-2#post-12795680

I was planning on a Ruger, then a Howa, but I've always loved a Remington. So I'm about 98% sure I want to get him a new Timney trigger Remington 700 in 308, which would be a short action. That takes care of him but I still don't have a rifle.

We will be shooting 100 yards and working our way out to 1000 yards eventually and just having fun. Neither of us hunt and outside of shooting at the range, I guess these rifles would be backup for Zombie sniping if the world ever ended and we were left alive. I've always wanted a M24 and was planning to piece together over time a M24 out of a new Remington 700 in 30-06. I reload and will probably never put factory ammo through either of our rifles. I was planning on a 30-06 because I really like 30cal and didn't plan on getting a 308 until my son showed interest. So with that being said, I'll be able to shoot his 700 as well so now I'm rethinking the 30-06 and I've also always wanted a 300 Win Mag. But would this be a stupid move? We won't shoot that much. Realistically, I'm guessing here...500 rounds yearly through each rifle.

I plan to start out cheap and always did and get a 700 ADL, buy a new M24 barrel later, HS stock, etc etc... So between 30-06 and 300 Win Mag, which would you do if you had access to a 308?

P.S. 300 Win Mag is badass
We don't hunt but dad has a really nice Remington 700 in 300WM. He put a massive muzzle brake on it so it shoots like a 5.56 lol.
 
I think he is trying to mentor his son.
A lot depends on the student and I wasn't going there. 🙂
But the recent range trip last week with my SIl's was a good example. I'm by no means an expert long range shooter or mentor, but I had them dialing in and ringing 600yds in no time. They've got a lot more to learn about judging wind than I do, but they were getting the elevation very quickly. No ballistic aps or kestrel used, just plain old spotting and dope.🙂
I'm liking his plan along with the .308 because he can use a lot of the same bullets in both and re-barrel as he mentioned if it comes to that.🙂
 
A lot depends on the student and I wasn't going there. 🙂
But the recent range trip last week with my SIl's was a good example. I'm by no means an expert long range shooter or mentor, but I had them dialing in and ringing 600yds in no time. They've got a lot more to learn about judging wind than I do, but they were getting the elevation very quickly. No ballistic aps or kestrel used, just plain old spotting and dope.🙂
I'm liking his plan along with the .308 because he can use a lot of the same bullets in both and re-barrel as he mentioned if it comes to that.🙂
I just noticed we were going diffrent directions both with good intention. If he ran a mag bolt face in a long action and started a 6.5 prc and moved up to 7prc when the barrel smoked it would work well but that doesn't fit his rem action. He could run a 308 in a long action and move to 30-06 giving room to run bullets like the berger 200'-20x which th 06 case capacity matters. The guy just needs a good plan and I don't see one in a belted mag action unless he's willing to run a 264 mag and then jump to a 300 mag. The 264 6.5 belted mag is a boss though.
 
Back
Top