adweisbe wrote:
Hilton Yam and George Smith have already explained the issues involved with external extractors in the 1911 including S&W's version.
I've reviewed some postings by Mr. Yam and don't see where he is critical of SW's extractor. He has stated:
"The Smith extractors have been exceedingly functional, and make the SW1911 a very reliable pistol, especially considering its price range."
"The internal extractor does not hold any advantage for an advanced user . . ."
"Given average execution of either design, the external extractor still has the edge:
-no hand fitting required to adjust hook dimensions
-no gauging, adjusting, or other black magic to achieve the desired tension
-spring temper of the component is not critical to proper function
-no fatiguing or damage of extractor from push feeding, Type III malfunction clearance (actual or drills), or chamber loading
-preventative maintenance requires only a drop in coil spring vs. replacing the entire component with another fitted unit."
"If you don't want them, then don't buy them. However, recognize that a properly executed external extractor design offers serious enhancements to functionality and durability for real world use."
http://www.10-8forums.com/ubbthreads/showflat.php?Cat=0&Number=317&an=0&page=1#317
Maybe I've missed something?