Ohio Open Carry Incident 3/22/09

Status
Not open for further replies.

FFMedic

Member
Joined
Feb 2, 2008
Messages
312
Open carry incident
3/22/2009
Louisville, OH

After some discussion with my close friend we both decided we would start open carrying of handguns where and when legal. He is 22, I am 23. We are both career firefighter paramedics from the area. Neither of us have a CCW or any type of criminal record. By all means we are both fine, upstanding “law abiding” citizens.

I had met my friend at his house and we decided we would walk to a Dairy Queen near his home, have our dinner and walk home. The weather was fair so a walk sounded nice. We strapped on our Fobus paddle holsters and firearms. I carried my Beretta 92 FS and my friend carried his .45 Sig Sauer. We were wearing sweaters and reminded each other to be mindful that they did not flop over the guns and conceal them in any way.

We began walking out of his neighborhood and enjoying the evening. The total distance one way was a little more than a mile. The streets we used were his neighborhood road, a fairly busy through street and finally the main street in town with sidewalks on each side. As we walked we did not notice any lingering stares and made no direct contact with anybody.

As we approached the Dairy Queen we double checked for any “No Weapons” signs or decals. There were none and we proceeded in calmly and naturally. We walked directly to the counter and politely ordered our food. I do not think any employees noticed our guns. We then filled our drinks and sat down. I did not notice any glares from other customers. Nobody seemed scared or uneasy. We did overhear two younger guys saying something to the effect of “they are probably cops”. We ate out dinner in a timely fashion, stood up, put our trash in the cans and exited the Dairy Queen.

We walked back the same way we came and in the same manner. A marked police car passed us and did not slow or turn around. After a few minutes we were nearly 9/10ths the way back to my friends home when we herd a siren “bleep” very close behind us. We turned around to see two marked cruisers about 15 feet behind us with their lights flashing.

The officer yelled out his window as he exited to put our hands up. We did so. The two uniformed officers exited and moved to us, hands on guns but still holstered. They ordered us to place our hands on the hoods of the cruiser and we did so. At this time a third officer in an unmarked car and out of uniform arrived.

The officer removed my magazine from my gun and asked me to slowly remove it from the holster and give it to him and I did. At this point one officer began inspecting our guns on and writing down information. He asked if it was registered to me and I replied that I purchased it lawfully in a face to face transaction. He also asked if I had ID and I replied no. I had not brought my wallet with me, only cash. I volunteered my name, address and date of birth.

At this point we were all in a very relaxed mood. We were not cuffed or even patted down for other weapons. I was also carrying a spare magazine and a folding knife. I was never asked if I had other weapons on me. The officers were quite polite although obviously disturbed. The off duty officer was the most hostile. He stated that we didn’t even look old enough to have handguns, asked if we were trying to prove something or act hard and also asked if we were scared. I simply replied that I like to armed when I can legally for the same reasons he does and that I was not scared.

One officer hinted that we may be “inducing panic” and I replied by stating “I have herd allegations of such before related to open carry” and smiled politely. He then asked us if we had CCWs. I replied that we did not but it is lawful to open carry in Ohio. They asked if we were worried people would get upset or panicked. I replied that it was not our intention to upset anyone in the process of open carrying. The off duty officer alleged he drove past us several times and that my sweatshirt was covering my gun, concealing it. I simply replied that “I have been very mindful to keep my weapon in the open”. The ranking officer on scene, a Lt. then asked where I worked and I told him I was a firefighter with two area departments. The off duty officer responded by saying I “should know better as a public safety official”. I did not respond.

At this point their dispatch had returned our info to them with no warrants and no priors. The officer who was a Lt. asked if I was a member of the NRA or any such group. I told him I was an NRA member and a Ohio Rifle and Pistol Association member. He replied that he wanted us to know that none of us are “anti-gun” and that he was a life member of the NRA, but that people were scared and had called several times reporting two men with guns and they had to investigate.

The officers now put the magazines back into our handguns and gave them back to us. The Lt. offered us a ride the rest of the way back to my friends house. We accepted the offer, mostly to see what further interaction he would have with us in the absence of the other two officers. On the ride back (very short) the three of us simply talked shop about some firearms and discovered we had some mutual friends. While riding in the back of the police car we had our loaded guns on us still so he obviously did not see us a threat. He let us out of the car at my friends house and we chatted some more about local shooting ranges. He also gave us his card and said if we could not find a CCW class soon to contact him and he would help us out as much as possible. We could have chatted longer but he received another call and had to respond. We shook hands and he left.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------
So what do we think? This was my first OC ever. I thought they did a good job but was a little upset that they hinted that we should not do this again.

FFMedic
 
From the way the story began, it ended about how I expected to. I'm glad the LEOs were polite. I would expect the same to happen the next time you go out while OCing. It's a shame that doing something legal results in a police response. It's legal here in Colorado, but you can be cited for diturbing the peace.

Do yourself a favor and get your CCP.
 
The off duty officer responded by saying I “should know better as a public safety official”

Wow... as a public safety official you know why you should be carrying a gun more than anybody!

I'm not surprised it happened, it just goes to show how ignorant people are about guns.
 
Sadly, OC is too much of a hassle to be practiced very often. Imagine how much time you would waste if you did that every day. I only OC when I am in the woods, not in the city. I wish people were less paranoid over a holstered weapon, but they are not. Get your CCW and save the OC for backpacking season. They like us to "keep it in the closet", and "don't ask, don't tell".

If they only knew how dangerous driving to work is... or that mouth full of prescription drugs... or that broken CO detector... or that helmet-free bike ride... or that fifth cheeseburger this week... they might not be so scared of guns.

...
 
You Should have Continued Your Walk! Make shure you are Not Discouraged Buy there Actions. If you had been doing Wrong They would have arrested you. That was the First Step in Educating the Public.
 
From the way the story began, it ended about how I expected to.
Yep....I had the same expectation.
I'm in Ohio also. I carry concealed because of the number of people in our state who end up being detained for open-carry. Yes, it is legal. But I just don't have the time nor the temperament to "educate" everyone.
Getting an Ohio License to Carry a Concealed Handgun is quick, easy, and worth the small investment.
 
Please continue to open carry as much as you like. The more people see you, the more they'll come to accept it, and the more others will also open carry.

You shouldn't feel compelled to carry concealed when you're doing nothing wrong.
 
I'll probably get slapped for this, but just because you have a right doesn't mean you should exercise it.

People are afraid of guns. If they see you with one, they will call the police, and the police will be obligated to 'interact' with you. Even if you get to know the police, they're eventually going to get annoyed by constantly having to respond to nuisance calls generated by your open carrying.

I undertsand the "use it or lose it" principal, but I don't think actively causing anti-gun sentiments in people is helpful.

It would be different if the police followed up with the complainants and explained that it was legal instead of hauling you off in a squad car, which is no doubt what everyone thought they saw.
 
I'll probably get slapped for this, but just because you have a right doesn't mean you should exercise it.

I see no problem with exercising your rights. People are afraid of guns because they rarely see law-abiding citizens carrying them. They only see the blood-lust of Hollywood gun toters, or the exasurbation of violence conducted by the gun-grabbing media. I praise those willing to deal with the hassle of OC'ing in todays world. These guys proved to both the cops and the d-bags who called them that not all gun owners are criminals.
 
I'll probably get slapped for this, but just because you have a right doesn't mean you should exercise it.
fishslap.gif
 
Police not willing and/or able to educate the public is what I see happening here. Had to "check it out" they say. How about informing the caller that open carry is legal and there is no crime being broken?
 
I should clarify my statement - I'm not saying you shouldn't exercise your right if you need to.

I'm saying that if you live in a relatively crime-free area and are simply carrying open for the sake of doing it, it's probably not going to help anything.

As far as
These guys proved to ... the d-bags who called them that not all gun owners are criminals.

I don't see how. For all intents and purposes, the complainants saw the two men taken away in a squad car.
 
How about informing the caller that open carry is legal and there is no crime being broken?
Not on your life. That would detract from the public's belief that only the police can be the sole defenders against evil.
 
"Not on your life. That would detract from the public idea that only the polce can be the sole protectors against evil."

hehehehe that gave me a chuckle :D
 
Just to be clear, the officer removed the magazine from a semi automatic handgun and then allowed you to remove it from your holster? At any point was the chamber cleared?
 
I have considered open carrying around here, but I'm not a fan of attention. If I ever had to pull my concealed piece to defend myself or others I'd try to stay of the news. So, getting on the radar for just carrying in the first place really isn't my style. I might have to do it one day just to help the cause though.
 
Waterhouse, you are correct. He removed the mag, had me remove the gun and give it to him. He then handed it to another officer who then cleared the chamber.

My friends gun was removed from his holster by the other officer.

FFMedic
 
A freind of mine was in the Marines during WWII at the battle of Okinawa,and at the end of the battle he was sent home because of a death in his family. He said he carried a .45 with 2 mags on planes, a boat, and trains from the Pacific to Ohio and no one said a thing to him. Of course that was then and this is now.
 
DHJenkins said:
KBintheSLC said:
These guys proved to ... the d-bags who called them that not all gun owners are criminals.
I don't see how. For all intents and purposes, the complainants saw the two men taken away in a squad car.

This is my issue with open-carry as "education of the public" - it doesn't seem like there is really a lot of room for education to take place. The only situation I can imagine in which it might take place would be if someone asks you if you're a police officer, you say no, and then go on to explain how open-carry rights work. But most people are not looking to get an education - they want to know if you're someone who is going to shoot them, and so they just call the cops rather than engaging you directly.

I'm not saying it can't have a good outcome, of course - I'm just saying that the way it usually goes down, it tends not to be in a situation where lots of learning takes place.
 
I would encourage you to continue to open carry. I think it is healthy for people to see good citizens open carrying. And the more they see it, the more they will accept it.

I open carry a lot and haven't had any problems because of it yet. I've had all sorts of other issues, but not surrounding open carry.

Clearly, as someone earlier mentioned, the officers knew you were doing things right or they would have arrested you. It is still amazing that you rode in their car with your guns on you.

I was thinking that two guys with guns was over the top for them and everyone that possibly called in. But it is probably a good idea to have a witness with you. Maybe just one of you should carry next time.
 
I don't blame the officers. Here's my suggestion for the future:

1) Carry ID on you.
2) Get a CCW
3) dress nicer when OCing.

1) You had no ID on you and no CCW. If I were a police officer I would say, "hmm, maybe this person is up to no good and taking advantage of the law."

2) You have no CCW. Remember that there are people on this very board who proudly proclaim that "they don't need a permit to carry" even when they legally do and talk about how they willingly break the law. There's a chance the officers thought you were one of those people. "No, sir, I don't need a permit..." but it certainly helps in discerning you from a trouble maker when you're exhibiting a firearm in public.

3) I have yet to hear the story of someone dressed in khakis, a button down, and a tie getting harassed for open carry. If you/we want to normalize this, dress up.
 
While I don't personally OC, I know several people who do. They carry some educational material in their pocket. I've seen a business card that has a quick summary of rights and laws of my state. Other folks just hand out flyers.
 
I'm saying that if you live in a relatively crime-free area and are simply carrying open for the sake of doing it, it's probably not going to help anything.

So you're an expert at determining when crime will happen? Any comment about dog attacks?:scrutiny:

The two guys didn't have their CC permits (and frankly shouldn't have to IMO). I've carried openly a few times, pretty much a non-issue except for the usual comments and questions.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top