Reloading a Single Action Revolver (Your thoughts)

Status
Not open for further replies.
I thought all the practical, how-to reloading questions about SA's had been re-answered by CAS in recent memory.



In this video, he's loading and shooting the 6th chamber, but similar technique can be used to eject spent cases and reload. If you have an empty chamber and you shoot one, you can just open the gate and load one. If you load six and shoot one, then open the gate turn one chamber, eject and reload.

This is from Denny Hansen in SWAT Magazine and applies to modern single-actions where six are loaded:

"If a single shot was fired without recocking the revolver, the loading gate would be opened, the cylinder turned clockwise, the empty round ejected and a fresh round inserted. If two shots were fired, it was simply a matter of opening the loading gate, ejecting a fired cartridge, inserting a loaded round, turning the cylinder and unloading/loading as above. If three shots were fired, the gun would be reloaded as if two rounds had been fired, and then turn the cylinder three more “clicks” to arrive at the first round fired."

As for the other questions about carrying a SA, it's all armchair chatter. The bottom line is that a person doesn't need to carry an ultralight gun, they don't need to have high-capacity, they don't need it to be big or small, they don't need to justify their choice with tactical reload speed, they don't have to have a minimum power factor, they don't need to carry a certain type of bullet, and they don't need to live in Bear country, to carry whatever they want. An armed service choosing a firearm and cartridge for duty issue has a responsibility to diligently make selections on behalf of other people that will be suited to their purpose. But you can choose whatever you like for yourself.
 
The fastest for me:
Gun in left palm
Roll cylinder with left thumb
Barrel up
Run ejector rod with right index
Empty them all
Barrel down
Still rolling the cylinder with left thumb
Load all 6

Same here, and it can be done pretty efficiently. Sometimes I rotate the cylinder with the middle and ring finger of my left hand. That creates a pull instead of the push with the thumb. I don’t think either one is better than the other.

Good topic. And I’ve never been in a situation/place where I would feel under armed with my SAA.
 
when i carry my BH loaded with .9mm, I keep an EC9S mag with me for speed loading. If im carrying it as a .357, I just do the dump pouch thing. Truth be told, i probably couldnt reload a bottom feeder in a high stress situation. Hopefully 6 will get me out of a jam long enough to fumble with cartridges.
Why not carry "the other" cylinder loaded, and use IT for reloading by swapping cylinders :what:
That's got to be faster than stabbing out 6 empties and poking in 6 new rounds.
it's what Clint did...
just sayin'
:D
 
A cylinder swap is a no-brainer for cap and ball revolvers. It could be a good option for a cartridge revolver, but by itself wouldn't allow the shooter to top-off. It's a worthwhile option to consider if reloads are important to your purpose. It can help to have a captured base-pin so you don't fumble it.



reload is at 2:32
 
I dunno, it seems sensible to me. The OP is aware other platforms are faster. He just wants to find the fastest, most efficient way to reload the platform he is using. Perfectly logical. Whatever method used should get smoother and therefore faster the more times it is done. I think Wyatt Earp reportedly said, “You must learn to be slow in a hurry”. Makes perfect sense to me no matter what you are doing.
 
Yeah but Clint didn't do it while he was being shot at and the Remington design retains the basepin.

Swapping cylinders sounds good until you try to actually do it quickly. Cylinders don't usually just pop right back in without some fiddling and expect to scratch the piss out of it trying to do it quickly. Not to mention that I don't particularly care for stopping in the middle of a gunfight to take my pistol apart. Drop the basepin and you're screwed.
 
Yeah but Clint didn't do it while he was being shot at and the Remington design retains the basepin.

Swapping cylinders sounds good until you try to actually do it quickly. Cylinders don't usually just pop right back in without some fiddling and expect to scratch the piss out of it trying to do it quickly. Not to mention that I don't particularly care for stopping in the middle of a gunfight to take my pistol apart. Drop the basepin and you're screwed.

It sounds like a swell idea, until you try to do it during an adrenaline dump... Shoot, just trying to swap AR mags during an adrenaline dump is like shoving a round peg into a square hole...
 
The easiest for my fumbling fingers:
Gun stays in right hand
open gate with right thumb
barrel up
eject with middle finger left hand
rotate cylinder with heel of left hand
barrel down
load with left hand
rotate cylinder with right thumb or index finger

Good videos...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top