Picking a MkII, 5.5" Bull vs Government, need help fast

Status
Not open for further replies.

Kharn

Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2002
Messages
3,999
Location
Maryland
As I totally suck with a pistol larger than a .22 (and my girlfriend wants to have one to plink with, which I agree with, currently she expends .45acp like its dirt cheap), I've decided to finally get off my butt and get a .22. The MkIIs have really drawn my eye, as they fit my (and my girlfriend's) hands well. My cousin has a 6 7/8" Target MkII that we both like and shoot relatively well with, so I've decided to stick with the grip arrangement that works for us. (In case you've seen my thread on the Taurus Model 65 over in Revolvers, I can buy one of those anytime because it has the integral safety locks, MkIIs dont and are becoming more expensive by the week as none made on/after 1/1/03 can be sold in the state)

I hit the local gunshops today, one dealer said Rugers couldnt be sold in MD (partially true, but he's not very personable so I didnt bother to correct him that old guns could still be sold), so he's not getting my business. The other dealer had a new blued Ruger MkII 5.5" bull barrel with target sights for $299+fees+tax, a new blued MkII Government for $399+fees+tax, and a used blued MkII Government for $260+fees+tax; handgun prices were non-negotiable, even if paying in cash. The "state fee" is $20 (thats a rant unto itself, and I'll get into that later, the state only charges the dealers $10) and tax is 5%, so I could get out of there for: $335, $439 and $281 respectively. The Governments were both model MK678G's, the MkII was a model MK512. Both models handled and felt equally well, and pointed naturally.

For comparison, a Taurus Mdl 94 was $299+fees+tax and an HK USP40C was $799+fees+tax.

The used Government caught my eye the most, it only had a few very fine scratches in the bluing near the barrel/receiver interface (I had to look hard to see them, there were like five in a swirl pattern, as if it had been moved while in contact with checkered metal, maybe a few other small scratches in other places) and looked to have been well taken care of. The gunstore guy didnt know the history of it, beyond it bring brought in on a trade. I didnt have a chance to check the bore or any of that fun stuff (was on my way home from work), so I'm not sure on how the internals look, but judging from its outer appearance, it should be ok.

I dont have the cash for the new Government, and the new 5.5" MkII is a little more than I'm willing to pay for one, but given the MD's integral handgun lock law, its a seller's market for most .22s (only Taurus and the Walther P22 have suitable integral locks), so high prices are the norm.

My problem is I just picked up my FAL reciever a week ago, so I have a while to go before I can buy another 'regulated firearm' and I'm afraid the used Government will disappear if I dont act fast and put down some money to hold it until I can start the paperwork.

Now onto the questions:
I've heard Ruger has excellent customer service, will they repair a gun for a second owner? Like if I buy the used Government, and it gives pie-plate sized groups at 7 yards from a rest, can I count on them to make it right?

Is $281ish out the door a good deal on a used Gov't? Should I jump on it, or go for the 5.5" model?

Kharn
 
I'd go used Government. It's not like these guns wear out, so you're saving $140 and getting a nicer class of Ruger. You could even have it refinished by Ruger for less than $140 and have a like new gun.

I'd consider a $260 Gov. in any location a decent deal.
 
I have both the govt comp target and the 5.5" bull barrel. I find the 5.5" bull to be a little more balanced. The govt comp target is a good choice if you plan to put any optics on it. The receiver is already drilled for a scope mount.
 
I have a 22/45 bull...and the extra weight of the barrel really steadies your shots.

Excellent, utterly reliable pistola.

attachment.php
 
I'd go for the Gov't Ruger... we have half a dozen here at the range... excellent weps for long term use...

(Normally I would recommend the P22 but since the Ruger, you said, fits..)
 
To your second question: I've found Ruger's service to be outstanding. When I've sent guns to them (twice), it was with no questions asked, they just take care of whomever owns a gun with their name on it.
 
Don't buy a government model. You are paying a lot of money to have Ruger sight the gun in and shoot at a target. You can do that yourself.

Don't buy a government competition model. You are paying for a lot of extras that you don't need. The government competition comes with "fancy" wood grips, scope mount and rings, drilled receiver for mount, flattened barrel to save weight, and a machined crown to improve accuracy. I have the wood grips and I think the Hogue rubber grip is far, far superior. The best scope mounting system for a Mark II is the SoLow system, which doesn't need any gunsmithing, so the stock rings and mount are just a waste of money, as is the drilling for the mount. Only the machining of the crown is of any value, but the Mark II tends to be so accurate that you have to be of High-Master caliber before the gun itself will hinder your accuracy. Few people reach that level.

I also feel that the 6 7/8" barrel of the government models is a hinderance. The sights are too far apart. So when focusing on the front post, the rear notch becomes too blurry. Shooting one handed helps this situation, but I find it a problem with a two handed grip. The long barrel is also heavy, even though the Competition model has a "slabside" barrel to reduce weight.

I have found the 5 1/2" bull barrel target model to be just about perfect. You simply cannot go wrong with this gun, and you'll never regret buying it. The model is KMK-512 for the stainless or MK-512 for the blue version. I've never shot my Competition model as well as I've shot my KMK-512.

All those prices seem high. I bought a my KMK-512 at Sportsmans Warehouse for $309 and my Competition model for $365, both of which are stainless. $399 for a blue government model sounds like a total rip-off.

You might want to search online for a gun. Gunbrokers is a good place to start. I'm sure others can suggests some online gun dealers. If nothing else it will help you get an idea of what these guns should cost.

Good Luck!
 
I think you guys are missing the fact that these guns can no longer be imported to Kharn's state, and that effects the pricing.

He also states that the USED Govt. is $260, which is close to the price of a standard bull anywhere else - so he's not paying for any extras.
 
I've decided to try to get the used Govt, I called the gunstore this morning, they want at least 1/3 down to hold a gun and the gunstore guy said it's iffy if the used Govt will still be around on Friday (when I get to drive myself in, carpooling the other days).
Since I've got three weeks before I can buy the thing, I think I'll wait until Friday to put some cash down on the used Govt; if it disappears before I get there its no biggie and I'll just call around in Waldorf (nearest largish city, they've got a bunch of gunshops over there) to find another used MkII before my 30 days are up.

Graystar:
The prices are high, but its Maryland, so the sellers can command whatever they want to, since we cant just order any MkII off a distributor's shelf. Any pistol coming into the state needs a spent shell casing, and any one made after 12/31/02 needs an integral lock, thus it can take a while to find a uncommon model that is NIB and legal for sale in MD. The Govt Comp model is way outside my reach due to the cost factor, and I dont need the tapped reciever or any of that fancy stuff.

Kharn
 
Last edited:
For the stated purpose, plinking, you can't go wrong with any of the three you've mentioned. I have the 5.5 bull MKII and love it. Great gun for just about anything.

Good Luck on Friday. If it's meant to be, it will be there. :D
 
The prices are high, but its Maryland, so the sellers can command whatever they want to, since we cant just order any MkII off a distributor's shelf. Any pistol coming into the state needs a spent shell casing, and any one made after 12/31/02 needs an integral lock, thus it can take a while to find a uncommon model that is NIB and legal for sale in MD. The Govt Comp model is way outside my reach due to the cost factor, and I dont need the tapped reciever or any of that fancy stuff

jeez that freakin blows man! when i picked up my walther NIB i was wondering what that caseing was for! so if someone moved to MD an had a firearm that didnt meet that criteria what do they do? you gotta sell it?
 
Willyjizz: I think you can keep it as long as you got it before you moved into the state, MD law hardly ever goes into possession of items, only the transfer of those items (Except unregistered "assault pistols", Mac10s, MicroUzis, etc, you cant have one of those and registration was stopped in 1996). Obviously, you'd have to read the section of the law to be sure.

Kharn
 
Great Ruger service

Ruger has a fairly well-tuned service apparatus that will repair/service their firearms no matter who the current owner is.

I can say that Ruger was one of the most pleasant companies to send in guns for repair. I will probably be sending in a Carter administration era Security Six for refinish sometime soon.

Mossberg was pretty respectable also. I broke the safety tab on my trigger group. When I called Mossberg, I explained that I didn't want to be without a functioning shotgun. Sent me a trigger group and asked that I send back the one with a broken safety tab.

Springfield Armory did a pretty good job of replacing sights that shot low on a 1911. Took about two weeks to get it back. Old scratches had been buffed out and whole top was reblued.

Glock USA was the worst. They had my pistol for 6 weeks and could never give me a straight answer as to when I would be getting it back. A major problem since I was planning on taking it to training. Three days before the class, I get the gun back with a cryptic note saying it was inspected and found to be in spec. Oddly the pistol was sporting a new slide stop. I will say that the G36 does work flawlessly now.

Bottom line: don't worry about Ruger honoring its warranty. They will make ANY Ruger right for ANY owner. So get the Gummint model as soon as you can!...Then post pics of the pistol and the target!
 
Jmbrowning:
I'm gonna grab that Govt like a soccer mom fighting over the latest & greatest toy at Walmart on Christmas Eve. I just need to wait 20 days from now before my one gun a month period is up, and then another 7-10 for the background check/waiting period to be completed (but they'll hold it for me once I get cash in their hands). Hopefully, its still there tomorrow, but I know what I'm doing during my lunch hour if it is. :D

Kharn
 
Go with the Gov't. It easy to add a red dot. And there's that good resale value. But, if you're like most Ruger owners you'll never get rid of it. I paid about $350 for mine and now have about $800 in it with all the super-duper (and worth every penny) add-ons. The add-on Comp actually made the biggest difference for 50 yard shooting and my gun loves Aguila SE High Velocity - which is a dead ringer for the old PMC Zapper. I use a red-dot most of the time, but a 10x scope allows 3/8 inch groups at the 50 yard line. I don't really understand it myself, but have turned down good money from some "Pro" shooters.

One thing about Ruger service - they ONLY FIX THEIR PARTS and will remove any add-ons not of their making.

Elliot
 
WOOHOO! The used Govt is mine!
$293 total and I can pick it up in a month (stupid 30 days between guns and 7-10 day wait...).

The sales guy probably thinks he made the easiest sale all day, I walked in, asked to see it, looked at it for two minutes to make sure it was good (a few small scratches here and there, mainly on each side where the reciever and barrel meet, a little finish missing from the breech face of the barrel between 11:00 and 1:00 and thats about it; safety clicked properly, bolt moved freely, etc) and then pulled out the checkbook and explained my situation. He was very accomodating once he realized I intended to pay the full asking price upfront rather than make installments. :evil:

One of the store's owners was suprised that it was priced that low and hadnt sold since I my visit on Monday. :D He even said I really, really lucked out; I think its because the sales tag was underneath the pistol so you could only see the 'New: $399' part of the tag and not the 'Used: $260' right below it (since the New Govt was sitting right next to it with its tag exposed, there probably wasnt much interest in the used one).

I forgot to ask if I get daily or weekly (or even hourly) visitation rights with my new toy until I can pick it up... :uhoh: :confused:

And I got this done on my lunch hour too, I love having the gunstore right outside the main gate. :D

Kharn
 
Man, i'm glad I don't live in maryland! :neener: In Iowa, AFAIK, as long as I have my permit to acquire, I can walk into any gun shop, plunk down the cash, and walk out with any gun without even a phone call. Heck, just last night I got my ruger 22/45 at a gun show for 209 (219 OTD), and today I'm going shooting. Without the permit, I can only get long guns, and it'll take a phone call for a background check, but I can still buy a couple at a time.

Not to say I'm special...I'm sure other states are just as lenient (if not more). I just like living in Iowa. :)
 
I see that this is moot now, but FWIW later on....

I noticed that you said that you GF goes through .45s like they were cheap, but didn't mention through what. If "what" is some sort of 1911 variant or clone, there's a dandy alternative that's relatively inexpensive and shouldn't be subject to at least most of the weirder provisos of your state's law.

The J.A. Ciener conversion units run about $200. I've had one for several years, and they work great. Same "feel", same trigger, etc. as your 1911, but ammo is $0.02/rd. Mine has been extremely reliable and accurate for uncounted thousands of rounds.

No fitting is required, and swapping uppers and magazines takes under a minute.

As it's not a "firearm" in and of itself as defined by Federal law, it shouldn't be subject to the BS in terms of "integral locks", waiting periods, sales and import restrictions, etc. you poor souls have been saddled with by your sheeple neighbors.

Congrats on your purchase, and condolences on the idiotic hoops that you had to jump through to get it.

When and if you feel the need for another option in a .22 pistol, and your .45 is a 1911-type, check out the conversion units. They're a hoot to shoot, and a real bargain.
 
Mainmech48:
As you correctly guessed, the culprits in my .45 stockpile depletion are my two 1911s. I was looking at the Ceiner kits, and my last resort plan was to buy one of the Platinum models (adjustable sights, supposedly more accurate, etc) if I couldnt find a .22 pistol I liked (but as you said, thats a moot point now).

Now that I have a target-grade .22 pistol with my name on it, my plan is leaning towards browsing for a used Ceiner around the November time-frame (we do most of our shooting when I am home on Christmas & Summer breaks), with no pressure to buy if I cant find one that is priced just right.

Kharn
 
How about this Ruger. :)

187L.gif


Probably the sweetest MKII that I have seen in a long long time! :)

It even comes with a "Gold Trigger" :)
 
I forgot to mention in my previous post, the gunstore guys mentioned that the pistol doesnt come with the Ruger box (I dont know about the manual or lock, but I was told it had the second mag). Does anyone think I'd have a chance of getting a freebie from Ruger? They list a price of $28 for one on their website, but I cant find a way to order it.

Kharn
 
Kharn,
Just my opinion, I doubt that Ruger will give up a $28 box for free, you might try EBAY they should be plentiful there. You kind of need to know the vintage of your new Ruger so you can get the proper box for it. Ruger will send you the users manual for free though... .02
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top