Which would you sell?

[greyling22]

forget values and replaceability. I'd say sell the one that gets shot the least. Or the one that gets taken out and fondled the least. I'd rather have 1 gun I love than 3 I'm only sort of in to.

 

[tomrkba]

None. Suck it up and take your lumps. Pay it off with your lunch money if you have to.

If I were forced to choose, I'd dump the Wilson Combat Beretta 92. There is no need for a gun that has half its slide cut off and a silly flip safety.

 

[Ohen Cepel]

I would likely let one of the long S&W's go since you have a spare there.

 

[leadcounsel]

Keep them all, sweet talk the boss.

 

[ADKWOODSMAN]

Forgo that coffee at starbucks and brew your own. You will have the money you need in no time. Save ALL guns.

 

[Walt Sherrill]

Forgo that coffee at starbucks and brew your own. You will have the money you need in no time. Save ALL guns.

Some guns ARE like GOLD and worth keeping. But I've sold or traded a number of mine over the years, and that has allowed me to end up with far better weapons -- guns that I really enjoy shooting, and admire when they're not being shot.

Keeping a so/so gun -- and despite my best efforts, I have had a few so/so (or worse) guns -- seems a bit like elevating a tool to religious icon status. I'd rather not, thank you.

If you've never bought a mediocre gun, then I'll understand.

If so, you've either been lucky, or have different tastes and standards than I do -- or are simply a much more discerning buyer. Either way, good for you.

 

[tarosean]

I'd dump the Wilson Combat Beretta 92. There is no need for a gun that has half its slide cut off and a silly flip safety.

Except the WC guns are decocker models w/o a Safety...

 

[Walt Sherrill]

Except the WC guns are decocker models w/o a Safety...

And, if we're talking about the WC Berrttas I've been reading about, they're not your average (run of the mill) Berettas; they've been acurized and are real tack drivers. If it's a less "custom" Beretta, then I agree -- sell the Beretta.

 

[Jim Watson]

Lessee, now.

Sig p226 tacops 9mm
I have a plain vanilla P226 CPO. It was not my cup of tea as an IDPA SSP so now it is my "house gun."

Dan wesson Eco 9mm
I have a SA Ultra Compact that is OK, a good IDPA BUG or CCP. But I carry something smaller.

S&W 627 PC 8rd 2"
A 2" N frame is just weird. Sell it.

Wilson Combat Beretta 92
Be interesting to work with but if it were not substantially better than the P226, I would let a Wilson buff have it.

S&W 686 no dash 8 3/8 exc cnd
S&W 586 no dash 8 3/8 exc cnd w/ box
S&W 17-4 8 3/8 exc cnd
I don't care for 8 3/8" S&Ws, but if you do, hang on to them, they will not be back, especially the blue guns. I would not part with my 4 and 6 inch versions.

 

[csa77]

dump the churched up beretta.

 

[saenzrich]

ouch! nice to hear the suggestions though. very helpful!