The slide on my M&P is rusting

Status
Not open for further replies.
Manco

The Glocks in question are not abused. They are used. I have seen my own guns get covered with fine dust, chaff, pollen, dirt, lint, when oiled out on the trails. Oil soaked gunk in a pistol is the number one cause of problems. When we are out and about we do not need problems. When we are out in subzero temps we do not need grease causing slugish slides failing our pistols. I have used grease that claimed proper function down to -40 that got thick at +20F. The lack of lube all over keeps the gun cleaner and running longer. If dirt, dust or whatnot does get in the gun (and it does) a good burst of air from the compressor puffs it all away, where oil will have it cling until you wipe it off. If the gun goes a week before it gets cleaned because thats how long it has been working, I know my Glock will not rust. I know because I have been using them for a minute. Every other gun I ever used like that has rusted. Even the 1022 stainless has permanent STAINS where it rusted and was cleaned off.

S&W has some good designs but they never keep a good model for too long. Someday the M&P will be a faddish memory and a new model will be out. 25 years from now it will not still be around in any form like it is now IF it survives that long. My G37 will work with the G17 upper on it. The G17 from 1989 works with the G37 upper on it. When the M&P hits 25+ years old and Glock parts still interchange, then the M&P might be able to be considered all that. Its a good gun, great design, held back by people who refuse to put a better trigger on it or a better finish. I would rather see a consistant carbon steel version that never rusts than have a 1 in 5 failure rate with a process that makes stainless more rustable than regular carbon steel. It is backwards thinking. They need to stop fiddling around. FIX the problems get over their name and bring the MSRP down to Glock levels and up to Glock quality levels and they will have a winner. They need to listen to the consumer. It is almost like they are marketing towards the ninjas that want black guns, oh and look its stainless!!!, costs alot more than a Glock....Has to be good!!!!

Great guns that need some design changes. The problem is the people sitting at the desk cutting checks to the advertisers. They need to direct that money to more R&D for the design....

They do have the BEST CS I have ever seen though. If he sends that gun to them it WILL be fixed right, fast and be back to him pronto. They got that going for them atleast....
 
Maybe I should have kept the two G19s I had. Maybe I should just carry my XD9SC instead. I will have to carry that when I send the M&P back to S&W (I am assuming they are going to stand behind their product)

This is a shame b/c I love shooting it etc, but now I am really thinking of selling it after I get this resolved & using something else as my carry weapon.
 
If it shoots good I would not sell it. I wouldnt even send it in. I would dura coat or gun kote it myself. If you do send it in, get ready for the best CS you will ever get, and fast..
 
I have had several, and still have a few, M&Ps and I have never had a speck of rust anywhere on any of them. Even on camping trips where we take dozens of guns out in Missouri humidity, where most come home with surface rust, the M&Ps are perfect. Give S&W a chance to make it right....they will.

Let us know what happens.
 
My M&P9 full-size goes kayaking with me and has ended up in the water with me. One time I couldn't clean/lube for about 10 hours later and it ended up with a drop of rust just behind the slide/striker cap. Other than that it was good to go even on the internals.

Damian
 
It's surprising how many people say to just send it in. This isn't a collector's edition Barbie Doll with a defective tiara. No wonder it's so expensive to run a company in the United States. Don't get me wrong. It would be one thing if the gun was defective. This would imply that when you got it back, this problem would be fixed. In this case, you'll get back the same gun. It'll just rust again. You'll waste time and money to ship it. You'll be out the gun for at least a week or 2. S&W spends time/money/materials to "fix" it. Your gun still rusts. The only winner is the shipping service.

Have you even tried cleaning the rust, yet? Try a couple drops of oil and 0000 steel wool?
 
Steel wool on stainless is a bad idea. The steel will embed in the stainless and act as a catalyst for future rusting problems.

Try it if you dont believe me.....
 
I have a Kel-Tec P11 that IWB carry daily directly against my skin without a holster (gun has a built-in hook) and work outside in NC heat/humidity.

I wipe it down weekly with a thin coat of Ballistol, which is non-toxic, and haven't seen a speck of rust on it in the 5 years I've been following this routine.

Since the M&P is an order of magnitude higher quality that my Kel-Tec, the Ballistol would probably help keep it rust free too IMHO. It's a great product, and might change your opinion of the gun.
 
It's surprising how many people say to just send it in. This isn't a collector's edition Barbie Doll with a defective tiara. No wonder it's so expensive to run a company in the United States. Don't get me wrong. It would be one thing if the gun was defective. This would imply that when you got it back, this problem would be fixed. In this case, you'll get back the same gun. It'll just rust again. You'll waste time and money to ship it. You'll be out the gun for at least a week or 2. S&W spends time/money/materials to "fix" it. Your gun still rusts. The only winner is the shipping service.

Have you even tried cleaning the rust, yet? Try a couple drops of oil and 0000 steel wool?

WINNER WINNER CHICKEN DINNER!....

Somebody who is realistic...
 
I'm so sick of hearing people complain about rust. Gun rust because they aren't being taken care of plain and simple.


you can't make a blanket statement like that. some guns have issues with improper finish/melonite treatments leading to rust, no matter how often you wipe it down.

did you not see all the previous posts attesting to this? :confused:
 
Never seen a Glock rust. Nor a modern all metal HK, or Walther or Beretta. i have

Never seen a Smith 3rd gen rust. i have

Never seen a Sigma rust. i have

The early XD's and HS 2000's rusted. I saw rust on a older Jehrico 941. And I have seen several 1911's rust (and many more that haven't). XD's still have intermittent rusting issues.

No excuse for the M&P to rust even in batches or every 4th or 5th one. agreed


........
 
Steel wool on stainless is a bad idea. The steel will embed in the stainless and act as a catalyst for future rusting problems.

Try it if you dont believe me.....

The weird thing is that millions of people do this to their stainless steel pots, pans, and sinks every day. But granted there may be a better way. Maybe scotchbrite pads?
 
different grade of stainless. We all know ordinance grade stainless rusts. Rubbing regular steel into the pores will only make it worse.

Like I said, try it.....
 
No. s&w has revolvers with titanium cylinders though. titanium is extremely lightweight--too lightweight to be made into a slide for an autopisto


Sorry, but you are Incorrect.

There was a Sigma with a Titanium slide available.

63zz3m.gif
 
Send it back to Smith. It is NOT a common problem with the series like some would like to say but Smith did have a run of them that were not treated properly to neutralize the salts in the finishing process and the slides would show rust. Melonite is a good finish when properly done but Smith did a poor job on some of them. I'm sure they will replace the slide in quick order.

Think about it, the slide is stainless steel. If it was just bare stainless it probably wouldn't have rusted like that. The finish has been improperly applied and it is causing the slide to rust prematurely.
 
I think you need a better maintenance regimen. Rust in a carry gun is usually a result of perspiration that's left on the gun, absorbed by the holster and the gun left wet or in the holster for extended time.

A light coat of oil and a daily wipe down with an oily rag at the end of the day will usually keep rust away. Refinishing will help and take care of the finish but if you don't make a concerted effort to avoid rusting it will be back.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top