Thanks everyone for the input so far! I appreciate it. Ill try to address some ideas floating arround since you took the time to reply. If I missed you its not purposely but I thank you also for contributing!
Sarduy:
both will work, but CCI have some 40gr flying at around 1450fps
Thanks the one
http://www.cci-ammunition.com/ballis...px?loadNo=0050
We have seen those rounds at the store also. After reading some other input we might shoot some of the Velocitor rounds next time out. But the Stinger rounds actually use a slightly longer case than the average 22LR.
Timthinker:
With a .22 long rifle cartridge, penetration is a paramount concern along with reliability. In a .22 carbine/rifle, I would favor the hollow point round since a longer barrel offers a greater possibility of both penetration and expansion. The one point I can not overemphasize is to make certain the person using a lever action can refire as rapidly as possible. This might prove necessary when facing a determined opponent.
This is the direction that I am leaning towards with the HP bullets. The expansion is important, I just want to make sure that it would have enough energy behind it to penetrate bone and muscle at about 10 yards. But we both work on rapid quick aim shooting at the range. The Marling 39 that we have can shoot them out really quick and right on target again. But the main concern IS reliability. Thats why it was down to these two rounds. But I do want to try the CCI Velocitor ones also.
EricShelton:
I don't know about those particular bullets, but if it's a lever action, I have trouble imagining running one type of ammo better than another.
Well the marlin 39a we shoot will eat any 22 lr, l, or s round we put into it. Its the extraction that sometimes causes a problem for us at the range. So far Winchester rounds give us extration problems in about 4x per 50 rounds. The Remington rounds have problem extracting about 2x per 50. And Federal rounds about 1x per 50. But out of all the CCI mini-mags we shot, there was never one extraction problem or misfire. That is why I want my wife to use this round in our backup home defense gun. Once the round fails to extract, a new round can not be feed until it is take out.
Aaryq:
Take the wife out and buy her something a little bigger. Some kind of 9mm carbine like a KelTec or HiPoint or even (if the budget allows) some kind of AR. It will be a lot more effective than a .22LR.
Eventually, that is in the works. We are looking at getting a Marlin 1894 in .357 mag/.38spl She REALLY hates the AR platform. So that is out of the question. But she enjoys shooting lever action and is good at it. So I would rather her use a rifle she is completely comfortable with. That is why we want to go with the Marlin 1894 eventually but that will be a while.
We arent to concerned with SHTF scenario at this time. This is mainly for intruder in the house and we are taking cover in the safe room situation. I will still have the primary big gun Remington 870 in my hands. In our Action Plan she is still taking cover with the Marlin and our son.
Aubrun1992:
Maybe, if you decide to buy something for home defense other than a .22, you could get a beretta cx4 storm in 9mm, 40, or 45?
Well again, our Rem870 is the primary defense weapon. She does not like to train with it so that is out of the question for her. But I will be carrying that. The 22 is the second line of defense for her to carry behind cover. Also buying her a 9mm or 45mm is different than her using it and being proficient with it. If I buy it for her and she doenst know how (or is uncomfortable) to use it, its no good to any of us. Especially in a high stress situation.
U.S.SFC RET
There is no way a perpetrator is going to take thirty rounds of this....
.22s are excellent for home defence as long as they are reliable and IMHO semi.
I think a perp would crap himself looking at that also lol I like that setup a lot. Wifey hates semi's though but trains a lot with the lever action and enjoys shooting those. Personally I think the training is worth more than the semi auto. I think for her, its a reliability thing. And if she "feels" that a weapon is more reliable I would rather her use that weapon than something she isnt used to.
Everyone else:
Thanks again so much. Im still giving it some thought (maybe to much thought lol) But I was leaning towards the HP bullets and it seems that most here feel the same. I will try out the velocitor rounds in a few weeks also.
Any other thoughts, keep them comming!
Vic