YAY! and OY! gun purchases.

Status
Not open for further replies.
What was wrong with the No 1? I'm a fan of them and thought that would be a pretty good sledge hammer.
It was, but I had no real use for it. It was beautiful, and it’s a wonderful design, but I’m not much of a rifle shooter to be honest. I mostly like lever actions. The recoil from that cartridge from a rifle, where you have no barrel/cylinder gap, was punishing in my opinion. Since I’m not killing big game, it served no purpose and I derived no joy from it.

Even with it very firmly planted on my shoulder, after 20 rounds of 200 gr ammo I had a massive bruise.

For some reason I find heavy recoiling handguns fun and challenging, and heavy recoiling rifles or shotgun loads really unpleasant. Maybe I just have a better understanding of how to shoot handguns.
 
Yay!: The Smith and Wesson 67-1 I got several months back, to replace the first sidearm I was issued back in 1987. That was a sought-out purchase.

An impulse-purchase that I feel lucky to have come across recently (I've had many over the decades) is a Seecamp .32. I had never seen one in the flesh before and, for what I paid, I feel I did well.

An impulse buy that I still haven't really figured out is my Mauser M2 .45. I actually thought I might carry this thing, being a double-action shooter. However, for its ammunition capacity relative to its, uh, girth, I'll learn the Remington R1S Enhanced Commander I already had.
 
YAY-Colt Combat Commander done up by Colt's Custom Gun Shop. This gun is still so very awesome in terms of it's reliability and accuracy that I bought it twice!

Browning Hi-Power Mk.II. This gun was everything my previous Hi-Power T Series wasn't: sights I could actually see, a trigger that was great right out of the box, and an ambi thumb safety that didn't require a mallet to put it on or take it off!

OY-The aforementioned Hi-Power T Series. Beautiful on the outside with that luxurious looking Browning bluing and those nicely checkered walnut grips, that was about it as far as nice things to say about this gun. A set of sights that I couldn't see, a trigger pull that was off the charts, and a safety that required a thumb busting effort to set it or swipe it off.
 
1. The "Yay!" category has to be topped by my 584-series Mini-14. That thing is an absolute hoot! Second to that would have to be my P365 which so far has exceeded expectations.

2. The "Oy!" category is led by the Colt 1911 Wiley Clapp gov model. That thing was a jammomatic on a good day. Sure, I could have had it sent in for service, but I was too soured by the experience that I didn't bother, and just got rid of it.

Honestly, my biggest "Oy!" moments were not so much why did I get a particular gun, but why did I get rid of a particular gun.
 
My biggest Yay has been single action revolvers. Always thought one would be neat, and made an impulse buy on a Heritage .357 at a good price a year or so ago. Have have added a couple more since, a Pietta in .45 Colt and a single six. That most likely is not the end of that, something about the manual of arms on a 4 click single action just really gives me a lot of shooting enjoyment. Also, how did it take me decades to find .45 Colt...

I haven't had any serious Oy purchases, but, probably the Keltec Sub2000 falls under that category. Not accurate or enjoyable enough to shoot to hold onto. The folding option was nice, but the portability isn't as useful as I thought if I don't really want to use it when I get wherever it is that I am going. I have had a few ARs and a few lever action centerfires that I just never really warmed up to also. They were fine guns, just didn't like them enough to keep them. A couple of larger frame .22 revolvers - a Taurus Tracker and a S&W Model 18 - just didn't appeal either.
 
Yay - The Model 28 S&W I bought twenty five years ago. It's been a pleasure to shoot ever since. Accompanying it is the Marlin in 357 I bought about two years afterwards. Had a local smith smooth the trigger and action then put Lyman sights on it. Very nice.

Yay - the Star Firestar in 45acp. It was my carry gun for years and for a compact 45 is a good shooter.

Oy - the Model 94 Taurus revolver in 22lr. I've put enough rounds through it that the trigger and action have smoothed out, but given the nature of 22 DA revolvers there's not much to be done for the heavy trigger pull.
 
My biggest recent 'yay' has been a Uberti SAA El Patron.
Fit, finish, accuracy, smoothness...all outstanding. I could own one of these in every caliber.

My "oy" was a Taurus tracker 7 shot. I'm not a Taurus basher, but it would not lock up, and get out of time.

Another "oy" was my little NAA mini. I tried hard to use it, but after its second trip back to NAA, I traded it.
 
Got a Radom P-64 for next to nothing. Makarov ammo, but it's not a range shooter. It's that great little "toss it in the pocket" and "go to" gun, in a viable defense caliber. BIG win, it's really grown on me.

Got a SBH Hunter, in 44 Mag, thing kicks like a mule on crack. Even gloves and an over-molded Hogue grip can't tame this pistol, and paid thru the nose, full retail, NIB, for this education, in high powered SAs. MAJOR "oy" . Not much point in a range pistol, if it's not much fun, at the range...
 
I can't say that I ever bought a gun on an impulse.
Every firearm I ever purchased was thought out and fully researched before I ever opened my wallet.
I guess that is why I have never sold any that I have bought.
 
Got a SBH Hunter, in 44 Mag, thing kicks like a mule on crack. Even gloves and an over-molded Hogue grip can't tame this pistol, and paid thru the nose, full retail, NIB, for this education, in high powered SAs. MAJOR "oy" . Not much point in a range pistol, if it's not much fun, at the range...
Run some .44 Specials through it. Once you see how much fun it can be, reload for it. You can run from mild to wild and do so economically with cast bullets.
 
I've never owned a derringer unless you count that 4 barrel bad idea COP .357. I've shot a Davis and I don't think I'd ever own one. Was the Bond Arms worse than the usual?
Actually it was a wonderfully made gun with great fit and finish. It’s just not fun to shoot IMO, I think 410 shot shells are a poor idea in handguns, and as with any derringer they get harder to shoot than is practical at more than 7 yards. Plus, only two rounds? There’s way better options for a small defense gun.

Nice gun, just not for me.

The COP is the one derringer I’d actually like to own, but purely for its unique nature. Not as a shooter. Considering their price though, I doubt it’ll ever happen.
 
Yay!
My Tikka T3 Lite in .270 Win. 2-3/4" 5 round groups at 500 meters!

Oy!!
Kimber 84M Select Grade that I was happy to see go away at 1/3 the price of what I had invested it.
 
Yay! Marlin 1894 CSBL.
Drawn to this one like a moth to a flame - love all things .357 Magnum. Felt uneasy (and a little dirty, thanks Cerberus) about buying it though. Working part time at a gun shop, I'd seen a number of Marlins come through in the last year that looked & felt just fine, but was hard to get some of those early Remlin abominations out of my head. Even with employee discounting, it's pricey for what it is, too. Too different from the usual lever action fare to hold any nostalgic value. Even with reloading, it's a lot more expensive than .22LR if used for plinking. Would do just fine as a short range hunter for the local game, but already have other light, handy rifles that cover not only short range but anything out to 300 yards easy. Home defense? Sure but again, already have that covered with options that are probably better.
But it looks cool. I had a bonus check from my other job in my pocket. And I wanted it.
After shooting at least 100 rounds through it every week since February started, it's my favorite gun. Fit & finish are plenty good, action is slick as buttered snot, it's more accurate than I anticipated, and I have more fun with it than any other gun I own or have owned. Love to look at it, carry it, shoulder it, work the action, and shoot it. Hell, I even like cleaning it.

Oy!! Henry single shot in .357 Magnum.
Kinda hate listing this one here. Very well made, beautiful walnut stock with lots of figure, great bluing. Pretty accurate too. Was more about how it fits me than how it looks & works. Just never felt right when I shouldered it, like the weight distribution was cattywompus. The only thing really "wrong" with it is the trigger. Almost 9 lbs, gritty and just plain awful. I polished things & changed springs, but best I could get it without causing light strikes was 5-1/2 lbs, still creepy & gritty. Common complaint with their single shots, weird since all the Henry lever actions I've shot have had pretty good triggers.
 
Cats of a different color!
Yay: limcat beastcat. Its big, bold and beautiful. Flattest shooting open class race gun i have ever had the pleasure of blasting. Absolutely love it.

OY: Springfield hellcat. Too small for my fingers, too difficult for my daughter to rack, osp model requires unobtanium optic. The little devil runs perfect but its not for me.
 
Dibbs: The P64 is a gun with lots of appeal for many of us.
The value of these guns might be very underrated.

Some of also want a handgun which has more than just 'acceptable' recoil, for range enjoyment.
Three friends carry/carried (one is deceased) them All the time, due to the pocket carry option and having more power than a .32.
 
I have had a few of each, but one may come as a surprise to some !

Yay: S&W 686+ 3"

Oy: S&W 686+ 4"

The 3" feels nicer in my hands & I shoot it better.
 
My biggest "OIY" <facepalm> of all time, wasn't one that I bought....it was one that I didnt buy!

Standing in the rack at the Illinois state ATA shoot a couple years ago was an 1894 Winchester .30-30 circa 1927, marked New Mexico State Penitentiary. It was a SRC, rough blueing, cigarette burns on the wood. It was rough but reeking with character.
It was $900 and I passed because I'm a stupid poorboy.
 
My biggest "OIY" <facepalm> of all time, wasn't one that I bought....it was one that I didnt buy!

Standing in the rack at the Illinois state ATA shoot a couple years ago was an 1894 Winchester .30-30 circa 1927, marked New Mexico State Penitentiary. It was a SRC, rough blueing, cigarette burns on the wood. It was rough but reeking with character.
It was $900 and I passed.
Here's to absent friends and missed opportunities.
 
I forgot one of my Oys.

Bond Arms Derringer. What a waste of money.

Let the angry comments commence.

I got a cheap derringer, made by Cobra. IMO, part of the allure of derringers IS that they are cheap. Now, if I'd spent what a Bond costs, I'd be pissed, too.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top