scaatylobo
Member
I am not trying to start "another caliber war".
I am asking what reasons YOU [ yes I need a reason ] would choose a PCC [ pistol caliber carbine ] in either .45acp or .9mm.
Is the penetration of the 9mm and the much newer and extreme ammunition and less weight / more ammo,worth the trade off to a much lighter bullet ?.
I visualize 2 scenarios that are worlds apart.
One is your carrying that PCC in a woods scenario and its is for S/D against any & everything = including bears.
Would the very much slower .45acp [ with MUCH less ammunition ] be worth the possibility that it would surely stop a bruin,or is that whistling Dixie up a goats butt ?.
Or the MUCH faster 9mm in either ball [ LOTS of penetration ] or frangible ammunition do the job better with a 'hail of bullets' that are easier to hold on target [ less recoil ] and lots of pwe pwe in the magazine ?.
I am presuming that all are AIMED SHOTS and not counting 'spray & pray'.
So,what y'all think on my second guessing myself.
This all started when I decided to buy a Ruger takedown PCC in 9mm,and was thinking I might need to wait for the .45acp version.
Second scenario was for home defense = do you still feel the same about the woods choice ?.
I am asking what reasons YOU [ yes I need a reason ] would choose a PCC [ pistol caliber carbine ] in either .45acp or .9mm.
Is the penetration of the 9mm and the much newer and extreme ammunition and less weight / more ammo,worth the trade off to a much lighter bullet ?.
I visualize 2 scenarios that are worlds apart.
One is your carrying that PCC in a woods scenario and its is for S/D against any & everything = including bears.
Would the very much slower .45acp [ with MUCH less ammunition ] be worth the possibility that it would surely stop a bruin,or is that whistling Dixie up a goats butt ?.
Or the MUCH faster 9mm in either ball [ LOTS of penetration ] or frangible ammunition do the job better with a 'hail of bullets' that are easier to hold on target [ less recoil ] and lots of pwe pwe in the magazine ?.
I am presuming that all are AIMED SHOTS and not counting 'spray & pray'.
So,what y'all think on my second guessing myself.
This all started when I decided to buy a Ruger takedown PCC in 9mm,and was thinking I might need to wait for the .45acp version.
Second scenario was for home defense = do you still feel the same about the woods choice ?.